Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Sweeps Day 1: Derek Flint Has Seen The NBC Version of THE OFFICE!!

I am – Hercules!!

Mike Judge, who wrote and directed “Office Space,” would have been a great choice to Americanize “The Office.” Writer-director Christopher Guest (“Waiting For Guffman,” “Best in Show,” “A Mighty Wind”) would have been another fantastic choice. But the man they should have built this pilot around is writer-director Richard Linklater (“Slacker,” “Dazed and Confused,” “Before Sunrise,” “Waking Life,” “School of Rock”), who just did a perfectly spectacular job with the HBO workplace pilot “$5.15/Hr.”

Instead, NBC got Judge’s “King of the Hill” partner, Greg Daniels, to pen the pilot and Ken Kwapis (“He Said She Said,” “Dunston Checks In,” “Beautician and the Beast”) to direct.

Our man “Derek Flint,” who’s been appraising major motion pictures for Ain’t It Cool since the Clinton administration, all but screams "You're fired!":

Hey Herc:

I haven't written anything in TV for a long time because I never see shows in advance like you do, except maybe for this time.

I mostly go to movie screenings, but the other night I was part of a recruited audience for the American version of the BBC masterpiece "The Office" that was held at a testing facility on Lankershim here in Hollywood.

People wonder if NBC's pilot of "The Office" is as bad as last year's bomb "Coupling."

The answer is no ... it's worse. The reason being that the original "Office" is a much better show. There's no way to improve upon it and to Americanize it doesn't do it justice.

Greg Daniels, who co-created the cartoon "King of the Hill," is behind this American version and they should have gotten his partner, Mike Judge, to do this as he clearly had more of a handle on the required low-key style as he showed in "Office Space."

Daniels makes the same mistake that "Coupling" did by basically copying the original so much that you might as well just ignore this and buy the DVDs from BBC Video.

The acting lacks the masterful underplaying of Ricky Gervais and company. A guy from "The Daily Show" tries to fill Ricky's shoes and can't. The American dude comes off as bland, uninteresting and really irritating.

I don't think all that many of the test group I sat with was as familiar with the original British series as I was. Still, it was painfully clear that nobody was liking this much. The lady next to me said she found it "depressing."

Another said it was like a worse version of "Andy Richter Controls The Universe" without the eye candy and dream sequences.

I say leave well enough alone. Since most critics, as well as smart viewers, know the original "Office," the reviews will be scathing.

I hope the American version of "The Office" stays closed.

Derek Flint





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Does this surprise anyone?
by williammunny
Apr 29th, 2004
09:51:57 AM
Does this surprise anyone?
by williammunny
Apr 29th, 2004
09:52:43 AM
As I make my way through the DVDs of OFFICE Season 2...
by Roguewriter
Apr 29th, 2004
09:55:12 AM
Not necessary to Americanize this show
by Big Jim
Apr 29th, 2004
09:56:01 AM
"Your a cock! Your a cock! Your a cock!"
by Chillin
Apr 29th, 2004
10:00:17 AM
Britify?
by jimmythesaint
Apr 29th, 2004
10:13:59 AM
Won't watch this
by mjbok1
Apr 29th, 2004
10:19:57 AM
british Magnum PI?
by GOATBOY500
Apr 29th, 2004
10:21:56 AM
Too bad.
by mortsleam
Apr 29th, 2004
10:30:21 AM
Magnum PI
by DesperateDan
Apr 29th, 2004
10:30:35 AM
Is the U.S.A the whole world?
by Denki
Apr 29th, 2004
10:31:16 AM
Higgens
by Toby O Notoby
Apr 29th, 2004
10:34:43 AM
David Brent
by Baba-Lou
Apr 29th, 2004
11:34:01 AM
spelling errors
by Baba-Lou
Apr 29th, 2004
11:35:33 AM
Andy Richter
by pants malone
Apr 29th, 2004
11:53:27 AM
The Office
by madzander1
Apr 29th, 2004
12:12:31 PM
Baba-Loser
by noclevernickname
Apr 29th, 2004
12:16:01 PM
Shocking News !!!
by Itchy
Apr 29th, 2004
12:27:13 PM
Why?
by ChorleyFM
Apr 29th, 2004
12:28:36 PM
I'll bet fat, middle americans will find it depressing and miss
by Big Bad Clone
Apr 29th, 2004
12:30:13 PM
C'mon Limeys!
by Olsen Twins_Fan
Apr 29th, 2004
12:34:24 PM
I Saw It Too: A Different Perspective
by StandandDeliver
Apr 29th, 2004
01:21:42 PM
Ken Kwapis
by StandandDeliver
Apr 29th, 2004
01:24:48 PM
Did anyone expect this to not suck nuts?
by Grando
Apr 29th, 2004
01:26:21 PM
So who's the rest of the cast anyway?
by mortsleam
Apr 29th, 2004
01:27:43 PM
Rest of Cast
by StandandDeliver
Apr 29th, 2004
01:32:17 PM
Denki.. an reply to your question
by Russman
Apr 29th, 2004
01:52:17 PM
"The Office: An American Workplace" http://www.imdb.com/title/t
by Declan_Swartz
Apr 29th, 2004
01:56:35 PM
Office take two
by Baba-Lou
Apr 29th, 2004
02:16:36 PM
Please remember that the US Population for the most part is stup
by Lou C.
Apr 29th, 2004
02:33:55 PM
Meanwhile, back in Iraq...
by Fitzcarraldo2
Apr 29th, 2004
02:34:18 PM
Thanks for the info, StandandDeliver
by mortsleam
Apr 29th, 2004
02:50:13 PM
Olsen Twin Nonce
by dreg
Apr 29th, 2004
02:55:16 PM
Wolf at the door has a point
by dreg
Apr 29th, 2004
02:59:46 PM
"Stupid and Ethnocentric?"
by vikingkitty
Apr 29th, 2004
03:47:19 PM
D'Reg, I don't want this turned into an "America is great debate
by vikingkitty
Apr 29th, 2004
03:55:59 PM
Has anyone tried to burn copies of "The Office" using DVDXCopy P
by vikingkitty
Apr 29th, 2004
04:01:48 PM
Fitzcarraldo, in answer to your question-
by Stan the Bat
Apr 29th, 2004
04:20:24 PM
-of course they don't.
by Stan the Bat
Apr 29th, 2004
04:23:57 PM
Gervais played the yanks!
by Goat13
Apr 29th, 2004
04:24:01 PM
uh, did you see a different version than i saw?
by jackylint
Apr 29th, 2004
04:26:44 PM
Ricky Gervais is barely involved with this version
by Big Bad Clone
Apr 29th, 2004
04:47:29 PM
the fact that this review conatined absolutey no specifics about
by mansep
Apr 29th, 2004
04:53:24 PM
Gervais Loves It
by StandandDeliver
Apr 29th, 2004
04:54:44 PM
A producer credit doesn't mean much...
by Roguewriter
Apr 29th, 2004
05:13:06 PM
Uniquely British . . .
by Olsen Twins_Fan
Apr 29th, 2004
05:24:06 PM
I am not getting involved in the America - AntiAmerica debate, B
by FluffyUnbound
Apr 29th, 2004
05:26:48 PM
I've Also Seen The US Version.
by Asterios
Apr 29th, 2004
06:45:09 PM
Made in Canada(the Industry)
by lazy13
Apr 29th, 2004
07:00:27 PM
Cheers to you all!!
by Redbox
Apr 29th, 2004
07:12:59 PM
I think you could do with a new dictionary
by Regman
Apr 29th, 2004
07:57:46 PM
Thank you "pants malone" for sticking up for ANDY RICHTER CTU.
by FrankDrebin
Apr 29th, 2004
08:15:03 PM
How about a British HAWAII FIVE-O? ISLE OF MAN!
by FrankDrebin
Apr 29th, 2004
08:20:14 PM
Why can'
by cornstalkwalker
Apr 29th, 2004
08:21:22 PM
Why does there always have to be a remake
by cornstalkwalker
Apr 29th, 2004
08:25:16 PM
regarding COUPLING...
by Captain Katanga
Apr 29th, 2004
08:37:59 PM
There's no way the US version will match the comic powerhouse th
by WarrenPerso
Apr 29th, 2004
09:26:14 PM
Cream of the Crap
by I Own You
Apr 29th, 2004
09:49:57 PM
Doomed to fail just like Arrested Development
by Under__Whelmed
Apr 30th, 2004
04:08:22 AM
Coupling
by DarthScotland
Apr 30th, 2004
04:27:54 AM
Ken Kwapis
by DJLetterbox
Apr 30th, 2004
04:37:27 AM
Reality Humor is as awful as Reality Shows
by clubsidetv
Apr 30th, 2004
10:17:22 AM
Last night's episode was good
by Lord Shatner
Apr 30th, 2004
11:17:26 AM
Query for "Olsen Twins Fan"
by Numorpheus
Apr 30th, 2004
10:45:14 PM
clubesidetv...
by DocPazuzu
May 1st, 2004
04:54:19 AM
I hate the term Americanized
by ejcarter9
May 1st, 2004
05:09:33 PM
Coupling and The office in the same space, tou utter wankers.
by Capt.Ahab
May 2nd, 2004
06:45:36 AM
Couldn't disagree more
by tambone
May 4th, 2004
12:42:14 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.