Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Harry's STAR WARS EPISODE TWO: ATTACK OF THE CLONES Final Film Review

Just got back from the 12:01am Screening in Austin at the Fabulous METROPOLITAN. Best National Chain managers in Austin. They organize and help keep the lines from getting out of hand. Let people in a bit at a time so that everyone could take their time getting to their seats. They made sure the sound would boom, the projector was bright and that we, the audience, were ready.

Quint and the lovely Auntie Meat had camped out holding our spot in line, I hated not being with them. But being on these crutches and having oral surgery really put a damper on my ‘line experience’ this time out. And I must say… I really miss doing it. It isn’t about the film, it is about the sense of community that builds around the theater. The feeling of family and unity when you walk in.

I showed up and got in line. Saw the folks in costume… A fellow from Chicago in Jedi robes was first in line and he was… moderately enthused about seeing the film…. Well, actually he was jazzed in the unable to stay still sort of way. Constantly pacing. Constantly looking around, the pressure of having stayed completely spoiler free on his brow. Looking at me, he sees answers, temptation… evil. Here, in the final hours, he faces his greatest danger… He comes over to show he has no fear. I saw his face, he was a word from bolting. "R2 is pink in this one!"

He runs.

The crowd was enthusiastic. Not ecstatic to be in line like the crowd of 1999. This isn’t the frantic long drought and the first water fountain in 16 years. This was a film some were fearing, some were hoping and all wanted to love.

For me… I was dying to see it. I wanted to avoid the news crews, this isn’t about me, the real story were the people that camped. Me, I’m just a fan that was lucky enough to have a friend that held my place. I didn’t deserve my position, I didn’t do the time. Injuries or not… My place was in line.

10:30 – we began marching into place. The line was excited… all a buzz. Getting closer.

10:45 – we enter into the actual screening room. The largest best screen in Austin. Just a wonderful place to see this type of movie.

I get my favorite seat. My best movie buddy at my side. Behind me a row of friends and Dad. People with light sabers and costumes litter the theater. Folks eager to see the film. Sporadic folks come up to thank me for the advance review I wrote, telling me that they weren’t gonna get in line early till they saw that. GULP, HOPE THEY LIKE THE MOVIE!

As the film was getting closer I was getting more and more excited. You see, I saw ATTACK OF THE CLONES before, but the print I had seen still needed MASSIVE POST-PRODUCTION work especially in the sound and sound effects editing and the music mixing stages. That stuff, simply wasn’t all done yet. Actually vast sequences hadn’t even a single sound effect, though some did. For example… those sonic mines that Jango shat out of the Slave 1? Well, zero sound there. End Jedi battle and Clone War… zero sound effects and score. The print I saw was seen on a tiny TV screen that my father had to run and secure from the house. Not my big television, but the tiny one. SIGH. So I saw it small, incomplete Fx, nearly at stage 2 sound wise and I needed to see it complete.

What would I notice different? Would I? After all it has been a few months now. How many major changes could there be?

Patch sitting next to was tired from a long day, had the beginnings of a headache, which she took Tylenol for. Quint was actually a bit nervous looking to be honest. He didn’t look entirely confident. I don’t know if that was just exhaustion or what, but he seemed a bit on the scurvy side. Father Geek was excited. Ever since March 16 it has been the two of us that have been able to talk about that experience. I haven’t wanted to spoil it for others.

The more that we talked through it, the more I loved it. Suffice to say, I’ve had a lot of time to digest my feelings about the film. Tonight was the final run-through.

The trailers before the film were completely unimportant. They were an aggravation, a tedious cacophony of meaningless babble. I’m sure they’ll all be great films, but I didn’t want to see trailers, I wanted to see ATTACK OF THE CLONES again, for the first time.

As the 20th Century Fox Fanfare played, cheers… Lucasfilm logo, cheers… ‘A Long Time Ago In A Galaxy Far Far Away’, cheers… The STAR WARS logo, cheers… as the crawl began… hushes and hushing… silence gathered across the theater as they were ready to listen to this evening’s chapter…

There is unrest in the Galactic Senate
Several hundred solar systems under
the leadership of the rebel leader, Count
Dooku, have declared their intentions to
secede from the Republic.

This separatist movement has made it
difficult for the limited number of
Jedi Knights to maintain peace and
order in the galaxy.

Senator Amidala, the former Queen of
Naboo, is returning to Coruscant
to vote on the critical issue
of creating an army to assist the
overwhelmed Jedi.

These three paragraphs set the film up. Count Dooku is leading a rebellion from the Republic. This has the Jedi spread out desperately trying to deal with the situation. Padme is returning to deal with the issue of creating a Republican army.

Now folks, there seems to be a lot of critics out there that couldn’t grasp or understand the plot of Episode 2. Apparently it was just too convoluted. Too dense. Too complicated to get. I’m going to try and explain very easily what is going on here.

First, we have an attempted assassination to set things in motion. Why? Senator Amidala was going to be the opposition leader against the creation of an Army for the Republic. Those that needed the Army of the Republic wanted her dead, she fears a dictatorship. OB1 and Anakin are assigned to protect her. In tracing a second assassination attempt back to an assassin, the assassin is killed leaving a mysterious flying backpack man taking off and a little dart. At this point, it becomes obvious that it is too dangerous to keep Amidala at Coruscant, but by sending a low-key Padawan Learner and not a high brow Jedi, she can keep a low profile and return safely to her planet where she will be protected in a safe environment. Meanwhile, OB1’s story is a mystery. Where is this dart from? He traces the dart to a system. Upon arrival he discovers a MILLION PLUS Clone Army trained and grown to fight for the Republic commissioned by a Jedi 10 years prior, who was allegedly killed before that. OB1 is asked to capture Jango Fett for questioning. He loses him and has to pursue him elsewhere. Meanwhile, we learn that the Dark Side is apparently clouding and interfering with the Jedi’s ability to use the Force. We don’t know How yet… YET.

Meanwhile, Anakin is in love with Padme, Padme is attracted to him. Why? He’s physically cute as a button. He loves her. Their situation is putting them in close independent proximity. They talk political philosophies, old times, dreams for the future. Young love. It doesn’t make sense. It isn’t supposed to. It simply is. Why is she not being hunted by bountyhunters now? Because she is effectively out of the way. The only reason the attempts were made was to secure the Trade Federation’s cooperation. And two, get a weaker minded individual into her voting place so that the Army of the Republic bill could come to pass. Anakin, like his son Luke, is compelled by a vision/dream of a loved one’s suffering. He rushes to aide his mother. Why hadn’t he done this before? Probably because he wanted to return to his mother as a full fledged Jedi, like she dreamed for him. Now I know he goes on a killing spree here folks, but the death of his mother isn’t the turning point for his character. Anakin hasn’t even been invited over yet. He is exploring it through his own lack of control. He still wants to be good. As much as he complains about OB1, he loves him. As much as he complains about the rules of the Jedi, it is his dream to become one. He just has some character flaws. Why did Yoda send him to guard Padme? Because she knew him, and he probably figured that it was time to trust Anakin. Let him get out a bit from under OB1’s wing. Push him out of the nest hoping that the experience would do him good.

Ok, meanwhile OB1 tracks Jango to a bug people planet, where he learns about a robot army being created and a plot to militarily overthrow the Republic and the Jedi. He alerts Anakin and Padme, who in turn alert Yoda and the Jedi Council. This situation serves as the impetus to give Palpatine WAR POWERS ACT, making him absolute ruler, till he decides he doesn’t need to be anymore. Riiiight. Jar Jar is not responsible solely for this. In actuality, it was Yoda and Mace Windu and Ki Adi Mundi that most aggressively need the help of this army to defeat this new threat.

This puts everything in stage for a big battle.

What is the goal of the battle? Well if you want to be a dictator, you pit two sides that you are allies with fight, with your enemy in the middle. The goal of this whole conflict was multi-fold.

1) Put Palpatine in position to assume War Powers, thus effectively making him a dictator.

2) Put the clone army at Palpatine’s fingertips.

3) Killing as many Jedi as possible in the crossfire, thus crippling their abilities to adequately uphold the law of the Republic.

4) Test the strength and weaken the Jedi. Watch how they respond and look for weaknesses.

By the time you reach the end of this film there should be many questions and things to ponder.

Who really put in the order for the Clone Army?

If in regards to the Sith there is always a Master and an Apprentice – is it possible that Sidious has multiple Apprentices? That he learned from the Sith’s last defeat?

What will be the final blow that pushes Anakin all the way from the light to darkness?

What happens that breaks Yoda’s nerve and sends him into hiding on a slimy mudball of a planet? His ultimate realization that the Jedi have essentially handed control of the Republic to the Sith, well that and whatever else happens crushes his confidence. The Yoda of Empire and the Yoda of Attack of the Clones are two very different characters. For this to work, something must complete the transformation.

How are the children (Luke and Leia) taken from Padme? Voluntarily? Dies during childbirth? What?

Are Palpatine and Sidious really the same person, or has Sidious grown a clone of himself with independence inhibitors allowing him to control a version of himself that he can step into now that he has assumed power?

Is the long assumed edge of a volcano fight between Anakin and Obi-Wan going to be a reality? Or does Lucas have another plan for how to complete his transformation?

What happens to Dooku?

What is Bail Organa’s part in all of this? His exhibition of frustration in that last shot on that balcony over-seeing the Clone army with Palpatine was quite indicative of his obvious dislike for the current situation.

How is Anakin and Padme split apart?

Then the big question… What do we not even have a clue about, that will affect things in the next chapter?

Now those are the questions on my mind at the end of this film.

DIGITAL FILMMAKING

The film print that I saw last night/this morning and throughout the weekend was gorgeous. There were a couple of key moments throughout the film where the background elements became very pixely. But these were few and far between. The worst of these was in Padme’s apartment during the conversation between Anakin and Kenobi. On Ewan’s reverse shot, the background was terribly blotchy.

I had talked with Robert Rodriguez about the ‘alleged problems’ with the High Def 24fp Sony Camera and Lucas’ STAR WARS: ATTACK OF THE CLONES and he told me that George had a couple of problems in the making of his film only because they were prototype cameras, and that the first HD lenses weren't as good as they are right now. Also, in scenes like the one above that I described are moments where George may have blown up an image over 250 times to get the shot he wanted. Robert said that he didn't have these problems on ONCE UPON A TIME IN MEXICO or SPY KIDS 2 because now there are newer lenses, plus he didn't blow up a shot more than 250% (which is still a lot.) To give you an idea, regular 35mm film, when you begin blowing it up, by the time you get to 50 to 75% it looks worse than those moments in ATTACK OF THE CLONES when it was blown up over 250%. Overmanipulation of any image, film or HD, will cause degradation.

Overall, this film is gorgeous. The colors pop, the look of the movie is like nothing I’ve really seen before. There are moments I found as beautiful as any I’ve seen in Science Fiction, and some that surpassed anything I’d seen before.

THE ROMANCE:

Much has been spoken about the Romance in ATTACK OF THE CLONES. For me it works. Sure it is a cliché, but cliché often happens to be a part of love. Everytime you buy the woman you love a rose, you are falling prey to cliché. When you buy a diamond ring for the wedding ring, you are experiencing cliché. Celebrating your anniversary is cliché. Putting on music, turning off the lights and lighting a candle… HUGE CLICHÉ.

As far as cliché goes, the romance between Anakin and Padme works very well for me. I have no doubt looking at Anakin that he is obsessively in love with Padme. I find it very easy to see why he would be. It is Natalie Portman. She has a way of disarming one. Her smile, those eyes… um, the rest of her. She’s a strong independent young woman who looks absolutely fantastic for her late twenties. What is she here… 26 – 28. Cuz wasn’t she supposed to be like 16-17 in the last one? Personally, I buy that.

The harder part of this romance is buying why Padme would fall for Anakin. I think the easiest excuse is just looking at him. He’s handsome as hell. Though that isn’t everything. Patch, who was sitting next to me was being creeped out by Anakin. His little smile when he’s told not to look at her that way. The way his eyes linger. These are all things that are just… creepy. It wasn’t till on Naboo, when they were totally alone, when there was no more need to look STRONG by others, that Anakin let a lot of his pompousness go. Suddenly you can see that there is a good kid in there. Someone that has been lonely, someone wanting desperately to be loved. He laughs at her jokes, no matter how stupid. He flirts with her, giggling about teasing a Senator. The pretend injury suffered from the grazing Naboo cow creature, the roll through the field, shared laughter. The memory of a single kiss. A kiss they both took. His desire to protect her. The shared memory of what has come before. She feels a certain amount of responsibility for Anakin. She was there, in his life, when he was taken from his mother and entered into a different life. These are the moments about which their love is based.

Padme is a public figure. Lonely and watched. Protected from most interactions. Her life threatened and endangered from her defeat of the Trade Federation years prior. She had one romantic interlude in her life that went wrong. Two people, two different standings in life. She longs for love, but is a sensible woman. Someone of position. There is no time for love in her life. She is bound by the responsibility of protecting her people and the Republic. That is what she has dedicated her life to, yet here is this young man. Powerful, in love with her, able to protect her from harm, attractive, flawed needing to be held and loved back. She fights it because she knows her involvement with him could jeopardize his career as a Jedi. But when the end is certain. When the have that moment before the flame of life seems moments from extinguishing… She professes her love. That moment can never be taken back. Suddenly the regret of opportunities not taken. The regret of not having love in her life, makes her crave it more than anything. When one’s life flashes before one’s eyes upon the precipice of death, she found what was missing in her life standing beside her. That’s why she loves him.

Where is all of that? Much of it is subtext, empathy and John Williams’ score. Glances in her eyes, frustration at being unable to speak. Watching Anakin suffer through the loss of his mother, tortured by visions of her mistreatment. Shared peril. All of this adds up to that kiss.

Love is a mostly unspoken thing for some found somewhere between a set of eyes staring back into one another. A pregnant pause that draws two closer to kiss.

JAR JAR BINKS:

I believe I now understand exactly what Jar Jar Binks was meant to be in the STAR WARS saga. Jar Jar Binks is essentially Lyndon Baines Johnson. When LBJ lobbied the Senate to give him special military powers to raise forces and deal with the problem in Vietnam, he had no idea how badly that was going to go. He didn’t see it through. He was seen as a goofy character with a funny accent and giant ears… No substitute for the great leader that he was asked to replace due to an assassination, which many claimed was because of his position on the War in Vietnam. (At least Oliver Stone thinks so.) Jar Jar listened to others in that big room and in wanting to do the right thing, but not having the patience or time to fully think through his actions, he ultimately finds himself a pawn in creating one of the great tragedies. Much like LBJ, his similarly big eared funny accented political leader from Texas. No wonder mesa always loved him.

RISE OF THE EMPEROR:

This is my primary love of the film. Sure the fights are cool, the effects are cool, Yoda is cool, Jango Fett is cool, Obi Wan Kenobi is cool, I like the romance, I dig the pieces and little moments throughout the film, but what I love more than anything is how George Lucas is handling the Emperor’s character.

This chapter of the STAR WARS saga is essentially the James Bond film to end all James Bond films. James Bond is divided into two characters. Obi Wan and Anakin. M is Yoda, who sends Obi Wan to handle the mystery of the dart and Anakin to safeguard the babe. Now contrary to 90% of the James Bond movies, M (aka Yoda) doesn’t tell Bond, "The guy you’ll be investigating is _____, you’ll find him at ________, your job is to ________ him and take control of _________." Hell, Yoda doesn’t even know that there is A) The Evil Master Plan, B) Giant Armies Massing, C) That getting the Senator off Coruscant is playing directly into the Evil guy’s hands.

I love that Scaramanga (aka Dooku) isn’t revealed all along. That he isn’t playing cat and mouse with Bond (aka Obi Wan) throughout the whole film. Instead Obi Wan’s mission is to catch OddJob/Jaws/Donald ‘Red’ Grant (aka Jango Fett) and bring him in for questioning. He doesn’t even know who this guy works for. Hasn’t a clue that by following him he’ll find himself at the big SPECTRE meeting with the big round table listening to how they are going to overthrow M and all his double O agents. Meanwhile the other Bond (aka Anakin) is all emotion. He’s the Bond trying to lay his lady down. Protect her from on top. Problem is, she is resistant to his charms. She finds Bond (aka Anakin) too cocky and sure of himself to start with, and only when Bond drops his pretension and begins communicating to her and exposing himself emotionally, does she begin to let him in. Then, of course when all the Bond information (Padme Safe/Bad Guys here) is sent to M, he sends all the agents, while M goes off to get the entirety of the British Armed Forces to lay waste to the enemy.

There is no victory though because it turns out that the Prime Minister is actually Blofeld disguised to look like Tony Blair, the man that M allegedly ultimately reports to.

What’s the point? The point is for this democracy to be turned into a dictatorship, those that protect the sanctity of the government and the ideals that keep it free… MUST BE ELIMINATED. That is the Jedi. If the Emperor reveals himself, his power ebbs. Hidden, behind the scenes, you control and push both sides of the chess match. If you control both sides long enough, you win. This is brilliant TAKE OVER THE UNIVERSE STRATEGY!

The lessons being taught here are everybit as important and relevant today… In the world we are currently in.

One can not empower a government or an individual to have limited controls over the freedoms we cherish, unlimited powers over our military and absolute power over a domestic police force to go hunting for traitors in our midst. No matter how nice the leader at the time may be, they can be taken out. They can be destroyed and the one that steps in could be the nightmare.

Is it over complicated?

Not for me. I can see it pretty clearly. This is fucking STAR WARS, it isn’t complicated. Ingmar Bergman and Luis Bunuel are complicated. They require deep thought, but this is pretty darn easy to follow stuff. And welcome distraction from the "Good guys on this side of the screen. Bad guys on that side of the screen. Now. GO!" that you see in James Bond films, Ahnuldt movies and the other Star Wars films.

Why does it need to be more than just the average A-B-C?

Because YODA isn’t supposed to go… "Hmmm, The Evil Palpatine it is. Destroy I must!" and just end it there.

This is the story of how centuries of peace fell apart. How a Government so sure of itself. So powerful. So Self-righteous and full of faux security could just hand the keys of the kingdom to EVIL INCARNATE.

Anakin… Vader… That’s a small piece to all of this. Stop being distracted by him, he isn’t the story. THE STORY IS THE FALL OF THE REPUBLIC, THE RISE OF THE EMPIRE and THE TRIUMPH OF THE REBELLION. These other stories are details that play a part in serving those three MAJOR plot constructs.

As for the much maligned dialogue, this part of the story is very different from the pre-existing Star Wars series. There is a lot going on, but I enjoyed particularly the banter between Obi Wan and Anakin.

Like this exchange:

OBI-WAN
If you'd spend as much time
working on your saber skills as
you do on your wit, young Padawan,
you would rival Master Yoda as a
swordsman.

ANAKIN
I thought I already did.

OBI-WAN
Only in your mind, my very young
apprentice.

Or here where OB1 exhibits his utter cool and Anakin his lack of cool…

ANAKIN
I think he's a she...

OBI-WAN
Then be extra careful...
(nods to a room)
Check it out.

OBI-WAN goes away.

ANAKIN
Where are you going, Master?

OBI-WAN
To get a drink.

I love how so much is revealed about Anakin in this tiny bit…

ANAKIN
Don't get me wrong... Obi-Wan is
a great mentor. As wise as Master
Yoda and as powerful as Master
Windu. I am truly thankful to be
his apprentice. Only... although
I'm a Padawan learner, in some
ways... a lot of ways... I'm ahead
of him.

Or this wonderful exchange between Padme and Anakin on their way to Naboo which I feel really details a lot of the regrets of following the path of the Jedi as well as serving as a foreplay of back and forth between Anakin and Padme in their discussions about the option of love:

PADMÉ
It must be difficult having sworn
your life to the Jedi... not being
able to visit the places you
like... or do the things you
like...

ANAKIN
Or be with the people I love.

PADMÉ
Are you allowed to love? I
thought that was forbidden for a
Jedi.

ANAKIN
Attachment is forbidden.
Possession is forbidden.
Compassion, which I would define
as unconditional love, is central
to a Jedi's life, so you might say
we're encouraged to love.

PADMÉ
You have changed so much

ANAKIN
You haven't changed a bit. You're
exactly the way I remember you in
my dreams.

Of course that is such a serious line. Here you can see Anakin creating his own definitions, allowing himself to love her, at the same time he is professing his love for her. Letting her know about the feelings he has for her and showing her how he’s not that little boy anymore, but someone that can love her. The rest of their dialogue is the clumsy back and forth dialogue of two people that have never really had love before. Anakin has never had it, Padme back before she was Queen. This isn’t mature love. This isn’t perfect love. This is unconditional love by inexperienced lovers forbidden to have what they have. Here’s their scene before going into the coliseum:

ANAKIN
Don't be afraid.

PADMÉ
I'm not afraid to die. I've been
dying a little bit each day since
you came back into my life.

ANAKIN
What are you talking about?

PADMÉ
I love you.

ANAKIN
You love me?! I thought we
decided not to fall in love. That
we would be forced to live a lie.
That it would destroy our lives...

PADMÉ
I think our lives are about to be
destroyed anyway. My love for you
is a puzzle, Annie, for which I
have no answers. I can't control
it... and now I don't care. I
truly, deeply love you, and before
we die I want you to know.

Now as a declaration of love between two people on the edge of death, I buy it. These are not Woody Allen and Diane Keaton… They are not mature people having loved and failed at it and tried again and again and again. Their hearts have never been broken. They haven’t been to whorehouses or strip clubs. These are two virgins pussyfooting about a love they’ve never experienced. You can’t judge it by what you would say, unless you happen to be a pussyfooting virgin or really and honestly can remember what the pussyfooting virgin in you once said and sounded like.

Roger Ebert said the most unsexy thing in the world is a declaration of love. WELCOME TO YOUNG LOVE, where the only thing a pair of unloved ears want to hear is that someone loves them and that they love back. And it always ends with a kiss. Lucas spares us the 2 minute copulation moment as Anakin releases too quickly, but frankly… that belongs offscreen.

As for humor, my favorite funny line came from Yoda:

YODA
Lost a planet, Master Obi-Wan has. How
embarrassing

I happen to have enjoyed C3P0’s funny comments. Did it lighten the moment? Yeah, but I also seem to remember in Empire Strikes Back while being chased through an Asteroid field by Tie Fighters and Star Destroyers, that wonderful gay robot spouting odds, and Han belting back one liners, all when they should just be silent and be navigating like hell. Or at the end of that film, where Threepio is riding R2’s ass about fixing him not the Falcon and being way way waaaay over the top. Frankly, you either like Threepio or not, I love ol Goldenrod.

Now every STAR WARS film has to have a line or two that I love. Frankly the "This party is over," line made me smile. I love the throw down line to Yoda from Dooku… In fact just about anything Christopher Lee said makes me happy. He is just that cool. But far above the rest, my favorite line… The one I’ll quote for the remainder of my years, months, days, hours or minutes that God or my cholesterol level lets me have on this planet is:

JANGO FETT
I'm just a simple man, trying to
make my way in the universe

Folks… I don’t know about you. Maybe you didn’t like this film. Personally, I can’t for a second understand that. This is the most intelligently plotted of the Star Wars films. The most viscerally exciting and thrilling of the Star Wars films. And frankly the most entertaining of the Star Wars films for me.

Not once is there a sequence that even vaguely recalls the horror and embarrassing stupidity of the song numbers in Return of the Jedi. Or the Ewoks in general. Jar Jar Binks is very limited and effective to me in this film.

Where does this film stand for me? Without a doubt above Jedi and Phantom. Somewhere in the top three for now. I’ve always fluctuated STAR WARS and EMPIRE STRIKES BACK… They’ve always sort of been back and forth depending upon my mood. Is this a lock for third? I’ll tell you after 10 more viewings. Right now, I’m excited because this, for me, is a STAR WARS movie. Saw with a great fun audience that overall seemed to really love it. Isn’t that what it is all ultimately about?

I mean, what is STAR WARS?

For me, STAR WARS is not just a movie, but a place to be transported. It is a fairy tale of basic human clichés and mythologies thrust against the backdrop of laser swords and space chariots. It’s a place where, "YAHOOOOO KID, NOW LET’S BLOW THIS PLACE AND GO HOME!" in the midst of a battle coming straight out of light speed sounds like the greatest fucking piece of dialogue since, "Louie, I think this is the beginning of a beautiful friendship!"

STAR WARS is magic, a magic of innocence and wonderment. And I love that the universe I grew up in as a kid is getting bigger. Adding planets like Geonosis and Kamino was great. Discovering why Boba Fett hates Jedi… wonderful. Just hearing the sound of that wonderful sonic mine… drop your dick cool. Way to go Ben! For me, watching Anakin and Padme’s romance, knowing that it is going to end badly, knowing that I have Han and Leia to look forward to when I end up watching all 6 of these back to back. I LOVE IT. I’m so glad their romance isn’t a mirror of that one. That it will be the story of woe theirs is the story of joy. Hearts crushed and mended in the same epic series.

I want that life. I want chairs that descend from the ceiling as those cool Kamino folk talk to me about my Clone army. I love that we get to see the street life of Coruscant. I love that after two months of having seen the film, after countless fucking interviews and chats and phone calls from long lost friends… that after all of that on a Thursday evening I still have somewhere close to 5500 words to say about the latest installment of the STAR WARS series and I could go on and on and on. That I can talk this stuff all night long and into the morning and the day after that.

I love that there is a new STAR WARS movie playing minutes from my house that literally makes me lose my shit with happiness. I love that in my chatrooms I can argue back and forth and cheer the merits and see elation from so many that they loved this chapter. And sure there are those out there that were disappointed or hated this film, but ya know what. It must suck to be you, because I saw STAR WARS: ATTACK OF THE CLONES and I can’t wait to see it again.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

It sucked, but for different reasons than TPM.
by xavier masterson
May 17th, 2002
04:40:00 AM
Agree totally with your closing paragraphy, Harry
by Meier
May 17th, 2002
04:59:05 AM
hmmm
by donner
May 17th, 2002
05:03:04 AM

by Dzobi-wan
May 17th, 2002
05:04:19 AM
I was an idiot
by Playhouse
May 17th, 2002
05:05:49 AM
I quite liked it.
by enigmainyourhead
May 17th, 2002
05:07:09 AM
Surprise, surprise.... ATTACK OF THE CLONES was actually pretty
by Psyclops
May 17th, 2002
05:10:03 AM
its all about the coke bottle race...
by Extant59
May 17th, 2002
05:14:07 AM
It did NOT suck !!!
by bluelou_boyle
May 17th, 2002
05:14:46 AM
Wow!!!!!
by Gabba-UK
May 17th, 2002
05:17:44 AM
MESA HAPPY
by Dzobi-wan
May 17th, 2002
05:23:12 AM
My Thoughts
by Fernwick_
May 17th, 2002
05:25:17 AM
Good Recovery
by Mr_P
May 17th, 2002
05:26:34 AM
Good read Harry but one thing!!!
by Rogue_Leader
May 17th, 2002
05:29:13 AM
Yoda! Yoda! Yoda!
by Gerbach
May 17th, 2002
05:30:20 AM
Sounds like Harry may be on to diagnosing whatever personality d
by dumbpeoplesuck
May 17th, 2002
05:30:24 AM
"George, All Is Forgiven for TPM"
by Nick15
May 17th, 2002
05:33:08 AM
another wow
by LoserTooch
May 17th, 2002
05:37:02 AM
Fucking amazing movie
by Anti-fanboy
May 17th, 2002
05:40:21 AM
Likes, Dislikes
by FatherMcGruder
May 17th, 2002
05:46:25 AM
Acting!!!
by WANKYBOLLOCKS
May 17th, 2002
05:50:21 AM
The Best film of the year
by EIFF
May 17th, 2002
05:57:04 AM
The dark side clouds everything
by Sigue Sigue
May 17th, 2002
05:58:34 AM
Thanks for that, Harry. If you didn't enjoy AOTC you're
by darthflagg
May 17th, 2002
06:00:30 AM
Right on, Harry!
by nverman
May 17th, 2002
06:06:01 AM
Anakin's breakdown
by FatherMcGruder
May 17th, 2002
06:07:02 AM
Have you even seen ROTJ?
by The Equalizer
May 17th, 2002
06:07:39 AM
That's all fine and good but again Harry, "WHERE THE HELL WA
by chuckrussel
May 17th, 2002
06:10:02 AM
I declare AOTC best SW film... ever!!!
by slav
May 17th, 2002
06:11:54 AM
interesting
by space_opera
May 17th, 2002
06:14:20 AM
Sad to say but,
by pogo on my own
May 17th, 2002
06:18:29 AM
Cringed at Anakin's acting
by Shepdog
May 17th, 2002
06:31:41 AM
it sucked a big time.
by 2vic
May 17th, 2002
06:34:39 AM
And you people complained about Jake Lloyd
by Dr.Zeus
May 17th, 2002
06:35:54 AM
I LOVED IT!!
by laguna_loire
May 17th, 2002
06:36:06 AM
"I wanted to avoid the news crews, this isn
by LlGHTST0RMER
May 17th, 2002
06:44:25 AM
'This cannot be decided by our knowledge of the Force alone.
by Silver_Joo
May 17th, 2002
06:52:11 AM
Shade: You said it
by Vegiterrorist
May 17th, 2002
06:52:47 AM
Herculoid...
by Sigue Sigue
May 17th, 2002
07:00:17 AM
I dunno why so many people are bitching about Christensen. He w
by cardinal_phantom
May 17th, 2002
07:01:19 AM
To hell with them so god will
by Mullah Knowles
May 17th, 2002
07:11:12 AM
Clones is worthy of the name Star Wars
by TallScott
May 17th, 2002
07:17:38 AM
Rocked
by Clone One
May 17th, 2002
07:19:58 AM
Now
by godawfull
May 17th, 2002
07:22:18 AM
Fuck you, Harry. Seriously.
by Rain_Dog
May 17th, 2002
07:24:19 AM
BEST Star Wars movie I've seen yet...
by elwen
May 17th, 2002
07:25:03 AM
the more I think about it...
by ARZAK
May 17th, 2002
07:39:13 AM
Wouldn't Owen recognize 3PO in the future?
by squidman
May 17th, 2002
07:39:34 AM
"Begun these Clone Wars have."
by moviemaniac-7
May 17th, 2002
07:39:38 AM
What an appalling piece of trash.
by The Gline
May 17th, 2002
07:41:22 AM
hmmmm.....
by Mad Dog
May 17th, 2002
07:43:26 AM
Harry - your best review ever
by Jabbathenutt
May 17th, 2002
07:43:54 AM
@ one with the force......
by McKenzieFrenzy
May 17th, 2002
07:50:28 AM
Godawful.
by Rain_Dog
May 17th, 2002
07:50:40 AM
Harry's in denial!!
by Demo
May 17th, 2002
07:51:00 AM
Ep. III
by Freakshow Lee
May 17th, 2002
07:51:09 AM
AOTC easily the wost of the series
by damo26
May 17th, 2002
07:54:16 AM
Urgent meessage to Phantom Editor: You've got work to do!!!!
by chicagojones
May 17th, 2002
07:55:08 AM
Somehow I doubt Boba will kill Mace Windu . . .
by Rain_Dog
May 17th, 2002
07:58:58 AM
You wanna know what happens in the last movie ?
by Nonkel Bob
May 17th, 2002
08:02:58 AM
complaints
by cheezman20
May 17th, 2002
08:11:31 AM
Hayden and DPL
by Fuckles
May 17th, 2002
08:15:58 AM
Is it just me or......
by CarrieM
May 17th, 2002
08:18:15 AM
everyone is a critic
by Frank Black
May 17th, 2002
08:20:52 AM
Amidala doesn't die in childbirth
by molloch
May 17th, 2002
08:30:46 AM
no sh*t this wasn't annie hall...
by Suede
May 17th, 2002
06:15:18 PM
WAY better than TPM! spoilers!
by ewem
May 17th, 2002
09:41:32 PM
WOW, WOW, and WOW!!! At least we have LOTR 2 and 3 to tide us o
by Atticus Finch
May 17th, 2002
10:52:14 PM
I can't believe I am saying this...
by Andy Andy
May 17th, 2002
10:55:33 PM
Liked many parts very much...
by viola123
May 17th, 2002
10:55:57 PM
It sucked, Lucas has lost it, the film was sloppy at best
by HerbChambers
May 17th, 2002
10:57:16 PM
Completely Unwatchable.
by Frijito Bandito
May 17th, 2002
11:01:12 PM
YOu people are on crack. That film ROCKED!
by Reverendz
May 18th, 2002
12:10:43 AM
this movie was the aborted fetus of
by bumetalman
May 18th, 2002
12:27:24 AM
disappointing on so many levels
by manhattom
May 18th, 2002
12:28:09 AM
You might be on crack if...
by Pageiv
May 18th, 2002
12:32:54 AM
What a Waste
by yoda04
May 18th, 2002
12:36:08 AM
next one
by alcester
May 18th, 2002
12:43:50 AM
Jesus Harry, would you give it a rest!! (now hear me speak)
by TheGinger Twit
May 18th, 2002
12:44:12 AM
an experience without emotion
by The_Black_Hair
May 18th, 2002
12:47:55 AM

by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
12:50:26 AM
Leia remembers her mother
by Merkin Muffley
May 18th, 2002
12:52:26 AM

by E.E.Smith
May 18th, 2002
12:52:30 AM
I agree...mostly
by shadowbox
May 18th, 2002
12:54:09 AM
It sucked until.........
by Chow Yun-Fat II
May 18th, 2002
12:57:16 AM
great.. not so great... and downright awful.. but very very amib
by waynesworld
May 18th, 2002
12:57:30 AM
Episode II
by E.E.Smith
May 18th, 2002
01:00:09 AM
The Emperor has no clothes!!!
by Big Rube
May 18th, 2002
01:02:40 AM
star wars movies
by fun guy
May 18th, 2002
01:04:08 AM
Orion's Angel, I bow down to your superior judgment . . .
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:06:10 AM
It's already free
by Pageiv
May 18th, 2002
01:08:26 AM
The Empirial March was bone chilling!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by JP3183
May 18th, 2002
01:09:24 AM
Once again, aimed at Orions Angel . . .
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:14:00 AM
Read this, Harry (Spoilers)
by BrianT
May 18th, 2002
01:14:39 AM
I don't get some people
by RickP66
May 18th, 2002
01:15:00 AM
No, best line was 'Die you jedi scum... om my, what am i say
by TheGinger Twit
May 18th, 2002
01:18:19 AM
Hey HerbChamber
by shadowbox
May 18th, 2002
01:20:00 AM
How come 3PO dosnt reconize anyone? BOO HOO
by Pageiv
May 18th, 2002
01:20:34 AM
"You were searching for the type of film you like."
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:20:49 AM
It ROCKED!
by Blackguard
May 18th, 2002
01:23:06 AM
My Two Cents
by earthworm777
May 18th, 2002
01:23:56 AM
Objective opinion from an amiable non-SW fan.
by Silver Badger
May 18th, 2002
01:25:19 AM
"Bitter, cynical pricks"
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:25:32 AM
you are all spoiled rotten... what a flick
by Methestel
May 18th, 2002
01:26:47 AM
Worthy review for a great movie
by CDG24
May 18th, 2002
01:27:14 AM
Oh I see.
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:27:52 AM
Oh I see.
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:29:24 AM
Fair enough. Flaming over.
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:36:37 AM
Okay OrionsAngel
by Pageiv
May 18th, 2002
01:36:58 AM
I CHALLENGE YOU HARRY! EVERYTHING that's wrong with EP2 in O
by Arrogancy
May 18th, 2002
01:39:15 AM
I never said . . .
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
01:39:50 AM
Hardcore fans may like it, but everyone else hates it
by Maximus21
May 18th, 2002
01:41:46 AM
I swear Anakin, you're going to be the death of me one day.
by Krueger
May 18th, 2002
01:47:04 AM
Why the acting seems wooden
by muckfire
May 18th, 2002
02:01:26 AM
Do yourself a favor...
by CHEET
May 18th, 2002
02:04:53 AM
This movie fucking rocked. All the haters on here are either a)
by The_Lion
May 18th, 2002
02:10:06 AM

by fladnaG
May 18th, 2002
02:11:22 AM
Amazing
by peblopeet
May 18th, 2002
02:12:59 AM
I Loved It !!!
by Ralph Wiggum
May 18th, 2002
02:13:15 AM
coolstuff
by sokitome
May 18th, 2002
02:13:56 AM
What the....?
by Bones9930
May 18th, 2002
02:16:14 AM
Exposing The Soft Underbelly of Fandom
by vergence
May 18th, 2002
02:16:26 AM
sucks to be me
by ryan mecum
May 18th, 2002
02:31:56 AM
I agree with most of what Harry said, but....
by Godai-kun
May 18th, 2002
02:33:11 AM
I HAVE A QUESTION FOR ALL STAR WARS FANS
by fladnaG
May 18th, 2002
02:34:16 AM
I'm sure
by Darth Melkor
May 18th, 2002
02:34:20 AM
Enjoyable for plot tie-ins, however wooden acting and grainy
by shadocontrol
May 18th, 2002
02:36:28 AM
Get yer freak on
by fatzombie
May 18th, 2002
02:37:42 AM
Give Harry a break
by kdrump1
May 18th, 2002
02:41:45 AM
MERCIFUL LORD LET THIS SERIES DIE!!!!
by Black Ceaser
May 18th, 2002
02:44:39 AM
I LOVED THIS MOVIE....
by CHEWBLACCA
May 18th, 2002
02:44:47 AM
If the acting was wooden because the characters were politicians
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
02:45:53 AM
free movies
by fun guy
May 18th, 2002
02:48:43 AM
Get over it, Darth Spooky
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
02:51:36 AM
Hell Yeah Chewblacka Bring on 2005 and THE END OF THIS SHIT!
by Black Ceaser
May 18th, 2002
02:56:19 AM
Hey RAIN DOG
by Darth Melkor
May 18th, 2002
03:02:53 AM
Sorry to say
by Pallando
May 18th, 2002
03:05:42 AM
Speculation
by Monkee804
May 18th, 2002
03:07:45 AM
Spooky.
by Rain_Dog
May 18th, 2002
03:08:16 AM
EPISODE ll WAS GREAT
by bk383
May 18th, 2002
03:10:35 AM
This movie will NOT make a shitload of money.
by empyreal0
May 18th, 2002
03:11:53 AM
Rain Dog 2
by Darth Melkor
May 18th, 2002
03:14:33 AM
Attack of the Clones
by Nameless1
May 18th, 2002
03:16:42 AM
Excuse me
by dogfish112
May 18th, 2002
03:16:44 AM
I just don't get it...
by Pongo
May 18th, 2002
03:17:39 AM
with regards to the Owen and Threepio thing...
by HoichiTheEarless
May 18th, 2002
03:21:27 AM
A Quantum Leap Better Than TPM
by billy_zardus
May 18th, 2002
03:22:06 AM
Zeekade
by Meier
May 18th, 2002
03:27:41 AM
Clones, sweet clones
by Noocyte
May 18th, 2002
03:32:28 AM
Can't we just agree to disagree
by HoichiTheEarless
May 18th, 2002
03:32:34 AM
AOTC is a big COSMIC LETDOWN
by CaptainMisery
May 18th, 2002
03:43:05 AM
proof positive .......
by rack
May 18th, 2002
03:52:57 AM
I liked it, a lot
by Radd
May 18th, 2002
03:55:47 AM
Sure the acting was a little weak here and there, and there was
by Darth Ranik
May 18th, 2002
03:59:41 AM
After all the negavties, still was a net gain
by plzabuzme
May 18th, 2002
04:04:56 AM
Hey rack! Question for you.
by Lezbo Milk
May 18th, 2002
04:06:32 AM
good if not mediocre 160 minute toy commercial
by 81666
May 18th, 2002
04:07:26 AM
Ok I'm a dipshit...rack was referencing anothers review...so
by Lezbo Milk
May 18th, 2002
04:13:36 AM
Yoda shouldn't have been the best thing in the film... but w
by Ishmae1
May 18th, 2002
04:15:32 AM
Awesome Harry!
by sparticusmaximus
May 18th, 2002
04:15:56 AM
Boooorrrr-innngggg
by fuldamobil
May 18th, 2002
04:19:48 AM
Anyway....
by symon
May 18th, 2002
04:25:40 AM
People like Herb and CapMisery are bitches
by EPdefender
May 18th, 2002
04:25:48 AM
Attachment Is Forbidden
by Bald Evil
May 18th, 2002
04:39:21 AM
I agree with Shade and Rain Dog
by Jimbits
May 18th, 2002
04:42:20 AM
UTTER DISAPPOINTMENT
by DECKERS
May 18th, 2002
04:42:47 AM
captain misery
by Usul
May 18th, 2002
04:43:15 AM
CaptainMisery, i'm suprised by your shallowness
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
04:47:44 AM
well, lezbo ....
by rack
May 18th, 2002
04:51:50 AM
Hey......
by SilentType
May 18th, 2002
04:59:07 AM
The dialogue
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
05:08:56 AM
Well Done Cpt. Misery
by SilentType
May 18th, 2002
05:12:10 AM
Sadly it's a miserably bad movie...
by the_pissboy1
May 18th, 2002
05:12:46 AM
please post your age .....
by rack
May 18th, 2002
05:16:12 AM
Pissboy
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
05:16:26 AM
Heyden Christiansen will never work again
by Porcupine
May 18th, 2002
05:33:11 AM

by Rhedeye
May 18th, 2002
05:36:02 AM
Attack of the Clones
by Mogran
May 18th, 2002
05:36:29 AM
CaptinMisery
by dogfish112
May 18th, 2002
05:36:49 AM
Porcupine
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
05:40:14 AM
BrianJones
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
05:48:59 AM
EZ 2 pleez ......
by rack
May 18th, 2002
05:51:28 AM
You negative people are fucking idiots....
by Marek
May 18th, 2002
05:56:01 AM
AOTC down to 55% on Rottentomatoes. LUCAS,STOP MAKING MOVIES
by chicagojones
May 18th, 2002
05:56:18 AM
someone tell knowles to ........
by rack
May 18th, 2002
06:12:07 AM
chicagojones
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
06:18:40 AM
Mace Windu
by Fernwick_
May 18th, 2002
06:19:42 AM
Darth Spooky
by Destroya
May 18th, 2002
06:21:38 AM
Disappointment
by Peareth
May 18th, 2002
06:24:16 AM
HE IS NOT DREAMING, IS MASTURBATING
by VincentSpain
May 18th, 2002
06:25:03 AM
Marek and AOTC apologists: You are complete morons
by Fanbot#1
May 18th, 2002
06:28:47 AM
Romance in AOTC is horrible, we must admit this fact .People was
by VincentSpain
May 18th, 2002
06:28:53 AM
Qui-Gon Jinn could have been EVIL
by maggot96
May 18th, 2002
06:28:55 AM

by damo26
May 18th, 2002
06:34:48 AM
I REALLY wanted to love this.....
by MrSINISTER
May 18th, 2002
06:35:24 AM
cgi is shit
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
06:36:09 AM
cgi is shit
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
06:38:06 AM
cgi is shit
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
06:38:44 AM
shit
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
06:44:00 AM
I have to agree with Alexandra Dupont....
by Almost Sexy
May 18th, 2002
06:44:51 AM
Ben's spontaneous ageing
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
07:03:30 AM
Ben's spontaneous ageing
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
07:04:00 AM
Ben's spontaneous ageing
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
07:04:27 AM
The Binks...
by FNORDknt
May 18th, 2002
07:09:29 AM
Sigue Sigue.....
by chicagojones
May 18th, 2002
07:09:43 AM
Apparently it was just too convoluted. Too dense! NO not really,
by MentallyMariah
May 18th, 2002
07:35:29 AM
Oh my god - SW hysteria
by JT Styler
May 18th, 2002
07:36:59 AM
Enigma
by Dig
May 18th, 2002
07:42:06 AM
Ebert's AOTC review
by RogueScribner
May 18th, 2002
07:42:58 AM
Enigma - Show some class
by JT Styler
May 18th, 2002
07:43:56 AM
One more thing
by Dig
May 18th, 2002
07:46:30 AM
Enigma, relax, take a pill, just walk away from the this whole d
by Fanbot#1
May 18th, 2002
07:52:08 AM
It's an enigma that The Enigma hasn't had a corony by no
by RogueScribner
May 18th, 2002
08:00:37 AM
"corony" was supposed to be "coronary"
by RogueScribner
May 18th, 2002
08:01:38 AM
GEORGE LUCAS HAS JERKED A FAT CREAMY LOAD ON YOU AOTC FACES AND
by Black Ceaser
May 18th, 2002
08:02:33 AM
Black Caesar
by JT Styler
May 18th, 2002
08:10:53 AM
Film
by Almost Sexy
May 18th, 2002
08:25:51 AM
Enigma: Please don't feel so bad : >() (That was my first a
by Almost Sexy
May 18th, 2002
08:27:43 AM
Aint It Cool News.Com: The Film Site For People Who Hate Movies
by TallScott
May 18th, 2002
08:36:20 AM
I still say this film was weak at best, total crap at worst.
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
08:37:53 AM
Enigma: For example, you might wanna skip right by Black Ceasar&
by Almost Sexy
May 18th, 2002
08:43:04 AM
Ha! These talkbacks would drive a priest to give up child moles
by justsomedude
May 18th, 2002
08:55:42 AM
make me laugh some more canteen boy
by Frank Black
May 18th, 2002
08:58:11 AM
AOTC- Favourable reviews - Why?
by JT Styler
May 18th, 2002
08:58:47 AM
AOTC- Favourable reviews - Why?
by JT Styler
May 18th, 2002
09:02:08 AM
Ackbar rules
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:04:20 AM
Watch for Jango's "low clearance"...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
09:07:29 AM
ben gets old
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:09:56 AM
I wanted to love it, and I do, however....
by khlestakov
May 18th, 2002
09:12:56 AM
An entertaining movie, this was.
by Chilli Kramer
May 18th, 2002
09:16:43 AM
Top ten SW worst ever
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:31:27 AM
Top ten SW worst ever
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:31:28 AM
Top ten SW worst ever
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:37:05 AM
A movie for the FANs.
by KixD2
May 18th, 2002
09:37:41 AM
Hope-Less: A Message From the Ministry Of Truth
by Yoor-Peon
May 18th, 2002
09:40:44 AM
What Movie Were The Naysayers Watching?
by Zignor
May 18th, 2002
09:41:58 AM
zignor
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:45:44 AM
FINAL WORD
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
09:53:23 AM
[BIG SPOILERS] WHY SOMEBODY MIGHT NOT LIKE THIS MOVIE...
by Dicio
May 18th, 2002
09:57:01 AM
Did anyone notice this ... ?
by Bozman
May 18th, 2002
09:58:11 AM
"literally makes me lose my shit with happiness"
by JuliusCsir
May 18th, 2002
10:00:03 AM
Denial?
by Zignor
May 18th, 2002
10:00:27 AM
Wow...
by MonkE
May 18th, 2002
10:02:01 AM
Yeah it sucks to be this let down...
by truman32
May 18th, 2002
10:05:36 AM
DENIAL
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:05:41 AM
Sucked ass
by Maceox
May 18th, 2002
10:10:43 AM
Attack of the Clones was awesome!
by mdmel5
May 18th, 2002
10:12:38 AM
Harry's Wrong: It IS All About Anakin
by Voice O. Reason
May 18th, 2002
10:16:33 AM
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Yoda (Some Spoilers)
by RobinP
May 18th, 2002
10:20:28 AM
The script was terrible, but
by Chilli Kramer
May 18th, 2002
10:21:14 AM
Sigue Sigue / Re: Yoda's lightsaber
by Deagle2
May 18th, 2002
10:29:11 AM
Damo26 and all nay-sayers.
by buffy3:16
May 18th, 2002
10:32:23 AM
THE REAL REASONS WHY THE FILM FAILS
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:34:14 AM
it's over clones...
by vergence
May 18th, 2002
10:37:47 AM
I'LL SHOUT IF I **CKING WANT TO!
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:37:50 AM
I just feel the need to say IT WAS AMAZING!!
by agentcooper
May 18th, 2002
10:46:39 AM
100% CGI
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:46:54 AM
You do realize that digital film is dramatically lower quality t
by marauderwd
May 18th, 2002
10:47:51 AM
100% CGI
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:49:28 AM
I hated The Phantom Menace more than anything I've ever seen
by SK909
May 18th, 2002
10:50:46 AM
shitty you were,yeeeeees.
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:52:02 AM
Using CGI is fine. Using CGI to mask a weak script and bad story
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
10:52:05 AM
GENERAL CUSTER...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
10:52:47 AM
yup, the audiences liked it....
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
10:53:54 AM
shitty you were,yeeeeees.
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
10:55:56 AM
so why are you here?
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
10:58:26 AM
Some people here need to get a life......
by sithapprentice
May 18th, 2002
11:06:20 AM
AOTC was great - only a couple small annoyances
by Riverdancer
May 18th, 2002
11:07:55 AM
GENERAL CUSTER
by EIFF
May 18th, 2002
11:11:14 AM
Goodbye forever, and I'll never listen to Harry again.
by damo26
May 18th, 2002
11:11:20 AM
damo...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
11:16:08 AM
The internet is a LOVELY thing...
by Sofa King
May 18th, 2002
11:22:40 AM
much better...
by gcshamman
May 18th, 2002
11:24:23 AM
Yoda should have been a muppett.....
by Kirk's Toupee
May 18th, 2002
11:24:51 AM
Ernst, you missed his point.
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
11:24:58 AM
Two Towers is gonna ROCK!!!!!
by Space Modulator
May 18th, 2002
11:30:59 AM
THE ONLY THINGS THE AUDIENCE LIKED WERE NOSTALGIC MOMENTS! STOP
by Arrogancy
May 18th, 2002
11:34:27 AM
BRING ON THE MATRIX SEQUELS!!!!
by Kampbell-Kid
May 18th, 2002
11:36:42 AM
IGN Filmforce will be interviewing Gary Kurtz
by Someguywithaname
May 18th, 2002
11:37:27 AM
Lidane...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
11:40:23 AM
A step in the right direction
by Swungdash
May 18th, 2002
11:41:03 AM
dear god, you geeky losers!
by cynicaster
May 18th, 2002
11:45:01 AM
Padme can't die during child birth
by AICNFan
May 18th, 2002
11:50:13 AM
Genius
by David Brent
May 18th, 2002
11:50:30 AM
Anakin's Not In Love, He's OBSESSED / Although an Improv
by NoCureForFools
May 18th, 2002
11:50:31 AM
I remember.....
by Wheatnik
May 18th, 2002
11:51:01 AM
only on the internet....
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
11:56:57 AM
When do we get to have fun?
by Aracuan Bird
May 18th, 2002
12:01:09 PM
Wheatnik, you're saying the WORSE a movie is, the YOUNGER we
by Arrogancy
May 18th, 2002
12:03:07 PM
Better than Menace or Jedi...As good as Empire
by Mil Mascaras
May 18th, 2002
12:22:02 PM
Has anyone thought of this yet?
by Entmoot
May 18th, 2002
12:30:26 PM
Harry, that was the best review you've ever done. Good job,
by jules windex
May 18th, 2002
12:30:58 PM
Clearly I've joined the Dark Side
by Wushuliu
May 18th, 2002
12:33:13 PM
Jango's Wild-west style shotgun twirl after shooting that Je
by togmeister
May 18th, 2002
12:33:55 PM
C'mon, This is obvious why Anakin didn't go back.
by Entmoot
May 18th, 2002
12:35:39 PM
If You Find Yourself Waiting For The Next Action Sequence To Get
by The Founder
May 18th, 2002
12:37:31 PM
Entmoot...
by Arrogancy
May 18th, 2002
12:40:31 PM
best performance...
by saintaugust
May 18th, 2002
12:46:49 PM
NO STORY! NO SUBTEXT! NO SURPRISES! NO CLIFFHANGERS! NO POIN
by Vynson
May 18th, 2002
12:47:13 PM
Why the Newer Movies have lost their Soul
by Verisof
May 18th, 2002
12:48:06 PM
Surprisingly Great
by Qwaz
May 18th, 2002
12:53:47 PM
LOTR: RIP
by jmachinder
May 18th, 2002
12:54:43 PM
I didn't go into this film trying to hate it.
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
12:55:41 PM
Overall, i loved it....
by spideyman1218
May 18th, 2002
12:56:13 PM
attack of the clones
by greenlightscafe
May 18th, 2002
12:58:57 PM
Prove me wrong, please
by Malik23
May 18th, 2002
01:10:46 PM
No. The PLOT is the Fall of the Republic, the STORY IS Anakin&#
by Drath
May 18th, 2002
01:15:48 PM
About the pillar
by JohnLocke59
May 18th, 2002
01:15:50 PM
Am I the only one who sees the OBVIOUS??? Anakin used his mindp
by Kikstad
May 18th, 2002
01:22:58 PM
I Loved AOTC but hated Phantom Mennace
by DARTH VOODOO
May 18th, 2002
01:28:33 PM
Why it's boring
by Arrogancy
May 18th, 2002
01:35:02 PM
Why Qui-Gonn didn't disappear...
by VespinFeebler
May 18th, 2002
01:36:28 PM
Don't attack this clone, for what he's about to say !
by luke_starkiller
May 18th, 2002
01:37:38 PM
Actually, i think AOTC is the BEST acted of all the SW movies so
by togmeister
May 18th, 2002
01:46:11 PM
i agree togmeister...
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
01:55:16 PM
Hey DESTROYA!
by Darth Melkor
May 18th, 2002
02:01:03 PM
AOTC must overcome backlash from Phantom Mennace
by DARTH VOODOO
May 18th, 2002
02:05:56 PM
AOTC IS MY FAVORITE STAR WARS!!
by hoorayforeric
May 18th, 2002
02:11:43 PM
BIG PROBLEMS
by esper999
May 18th, 2002
02:13:09 PM
AOTC is a very good if not great Star Wars film
by DARTH VOODOO
May 18th, 2002
02:13:34 PM
Surprising indeed
by Superdudebobby
May 18th, 2002
02:16:36 PM
Poor scripting, editng and pacing; good to awesome visuals
by Red Giant
May 18th, 2002
02:17:28 PM
ATTACK OF THE CLONE SETS BOX OFFICE RECORD FOR MID WEEK OPENING
by DARTH VOODOO
May 18th, 2002
02:22:21 PM
someone needs to point out examples where the editing and pacing
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
02:24:56 PM
No, Leia cannot be older than Luke. DUH!
by Riverdancer
May 18th, 2002
02:25:58 PM
funny thing about the box office...
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
02:27:29 PM
I think the main problem people have is this:
by Riverdancer
May 18th, 2002
02:32:49 PM
An easy analogy
by WarTourist
May 18th, 2002
02:35:15 PM
http://www.petitiononline.com/ ingorant/petition.html
by Specter22
May 18th, 2002
02:35:46 PM
majorq, try reading , the editing problems were pointed out MANY
by Arrogancy
May 18th, 2002
02:37:41 PM
The audience laughed at Yoda?
by Cap'n Chaos!
May 18th, 2002
02:38:03 PM
Thank You Harry
by erasmus1
May 18th, 2002
02:39:59 PM
AOTC in at No. 113 in IMDB all-time chart, just so you know.....
by togmeister
May 18th, 2002
02:45:33 PM
The entire Top 250 from IMDb
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
02:55:17 PM
the question you should be asking yourself is what changed in yo
by durhay
May 18th, 2002
02:55:28 PM
Some questions to answer
by Red Giant
May 18th, 2002
02:56:27 PM
You will pay for your lack of vision...
by General Idea
May 18th, 2002
03:06:17 PM
You Need To See AOTC More Than Once To Fully Understand/Apprecia
by PaulMrStarWars
May 18th, 2002
03:10:35 PM
AOTC takes $25 million on Friday - TPM's first Friday was $1
by togmeister
May 18th, 2002
03:16:00 PM
Disappointed
by dario argento
May 18th, 2002
03:20:12 PM
mystery voice during tuskin slaughter
by Reverend Rotund
May 18th, 2002
03:20:25 PM
Coke vs. Pepsi
by PurityOfEssence
May 18th, 2002
03:23:49 PM
Box office totals mean two things-- Jack and Sh*t
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
03:28:31 PM
I'm with you, Cap'n Chaos: Yoda RULES
by filops
May 18th, 2002
03:29:25 PM
This movie rocks!!
by JackBurton__ME!
May 18th, 2002
03:40:22 PM
Heehee Damo26, you crack me up!
by BarrelRider
May 18th, 2002
03:40:30 PM
Clones Rocked
by Strafe
May 18th, 2002
03:45:07 PM
not so big plot problems esper999
by Reverend Rotund
May 18th, 2002
03:50:43 PM
The big problem
by The Praetor
May 18th, 2002
03:51:26 PM
My thoughts on AOTC ...
by hktelemacher
May 18th, 2002
03:51:33 PM
All this darkness AND a PG rating?
by ProzacMorris
May 18th, 2002
03:51:56 PM
Read the whole post and tell me if you agree
by SilenceofFreedom
May 18th, 2002
04:00:22 PM
Rats
by PurityOfEssence
May 18th, 2002
04:01:57 PM
THANK YOU GEORGE LUCAS
by TIAMUTT
May 18th, 2002
04:03:07 PM
more points...
by General Idea
May 18th, 2002
04:03:14 PM
If AOTC had come out before TPM you lot would be knocking one ou
by Gabba-UK
May 18th, 2002
04:03:16 PM
This film is just amazing.
by sparticusmaximus
May 18th, 2002
04:15:16 PM
What the hell?!?
by Cap'n Chaos!
May 18th, 2002
04:15:55 PM
AOTC
by SoonerSean
May 18th, 2002
04:16:00 PM
Yoda04, you are not getting away with such a completely fucked u
by Andy Andy
May 18th, 2002
04:20:06 PM
It SUCKED SUCKED SUCKED
by dmezei
May 18th, 2002
04:23:28 PM
Harry, you're a sympathiser, not a movie reviewer.
by dmezei
May 18th, 2002
04:24:35 PM
Oh, by the way, Anikin got his hand chopped off. That complete
by Black Ceaser
May 18th, 2002
04:26:02 PM
Time to sign my petition
by Xoxarle
May 18th, 2002
04:26:18 PM
If You Didn't Like This Movie Then You Are Not A True Star W
by nicknster
May 18th, 2002
04:28:16 PM
Hmmm, this talkback is populated with Lucas plants...
by dmezei
May 18th, 2002
04:31:47 PM
Thoughts on digital movies
by yo0o0oy
May 18th, 2002
04:36:43 PM
If you LIKED this movie then you are not a true FILM fan.
by Black Ceaser
May 18th, 2002
04:37:51 PM
Addressing some of your queries...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
04:39:07 PM
Riverdancer: So now we are jaded since we are older?
by Red Giant
May 18th, 2002
04:41:32 PM
What
by Riverdancer
May 18th, 2002
04:42:26 PM
Call for investigation
by Ice Blended
May 18th, 2002
04:44:47 PM
God, it is hilarious watching the haters try to put down AOTC wi
by Atticus Finch
May 18th, 2002
04:45:54 PM
I really enjoyed it
by Kane
May 18th, 2002
04:47:43 PM
First???
by Movie Marty
May 18th, 2002
04:48:13 PM
What is wrong with Anakin losing his hand??
by Riverdancer
May 18th, 2002
04:48:43 PM
Spoilers in here.. Lucas is laughing at us :)
by james175
May 18th, 2002
04:53:35 PM
sometimes Yoda's diction a bit fucked-up was
by BarrelRider
May 18th, 2002
04:53:50 PM
Red Giant...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
04:55:34 PM
An Episode III thought ...
by hktelemacher
May 18th, 2002
04:56:58 PM
AOTC's rocked big time in DLP
by FunkyChicken
May 18th, 2002
04:59:22 PM
Anybody heard Qui-Gonn?
by kdrump1
May 18th, 2002
05:00:31 PM
Anybody heard Qui-Gonn?
by kdrump1
May 18th, 2002
05:01:51 PM
Why is it....?
by Gabba-UK
May 18th, 2002
05:02:17 PM
I Give it a 5!
by HollyS
May 18th, 2002
05:04:34 PM
Return of the DORKS
by wadew
May 18th, 2002
05:05:12 PM
THANKS HARRY
by johnke
May 18th, 2002
05:07:14 PM
hmmmm...
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
05:08:08 PM
Great unforced cameos,Thanks Lucas!
by TSMinN.Y.
May 18th, 2002
05:09:24 PM
AOTC
by Lolz
May 18th, 2002
05:09:42 PM
I was thinking.......
by moose420
May 18th, 2002
05:10:18 PM
I'm still wondering...
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
05:25:28 PM
Dialogue
by gilker
May 18th, 2002
05:28:39 PM
To all the haters
by TheDrunkenJedi
May 18th, 2002
05:36:11 PM
Comments about answers to my questions
by Red Giant
May 18th, 2002
05:36:37 PM
i think we are all forgetting something very important here...
by Flagg
May 18th, 2002
05:37:43 PM
"I Just Had To Look, Having Read The Book..." OR MACE IS A FUCK
by jollydwarf
May 18th, 2002
05:38:57 PM
People Need to Relax!
by HollyS
May 18th, 2002
05:41:10 PM
Owen's age
by Sigue Sigue
May 18th, 2002
05:45:07 PM
I saw it, was *really* entertained and now I want to see it agai
by steve_zodiac
May 18th, 2002
05:57:41 PM
I loved this movie!!!
by Darth Sanford
May 18th, 2002
05:59:21 PM
About the Starship Troopers comment
by Red Giant
May 18th, 2002
06:00:59 PM
Episode III
by mascan
May 18th, 2002
06:05:12 PM
sad...
by TheDrunkenJedi
May 18th, 2002
06:06:15 PM
The final nail in the Star Wars coffin.
by Roosterbooster
May 18th, 2002
06:15:12 PM
MOANING GITS!!!!!!!!!
by glaswallace
May 18th, 2002
06:27:27 PM
Movie fan and SW fan in restaurant.
by Xoxarle
May 18th, 2002
06:29:11 PM
Sigh...
by hailredskins
May 18th, 2002
06:34:26 PM
See it again! See it again!
by Playhouse
May 18th, 2002
06:40:04 PM
AOTC was pretty good
by GREGORRE
May 18th, 2002
06:41:18 PM
You havent seen anything yet
by Miss Aura
May 18th, 2002
06:45:47 PM
anyone else thought this movie looked soft?
by audiris
May 18th, 2002
07:02:07 PM
Lets play count the blatant influences.
by Xoxarle
May 18th, 2002
07:06:03 PM
OK..."I really dont care for you or whatever you are thinking.".
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
07:06:43 PM
Well done, Harry
by jsulbyrne
May 18th, 2002
07:17:35 PM
Hey Xoxarle ever hear of The Hidden Fortress by Kurosawa?
by PimpeeMcGee
May 18th, 2002
07:20:20 PM
Preditction: A lot of the people that clapped and cheered at the
by Kiyone
May 18th, 2002
07:20:58 PM
It was okay
by WinkinBlinkinNod
May 18th, 2002
07:21:35 PM
Ahem...
by Flagg
May 18th, 2002
07:22:17 PM
Slowbro, a couple more
by Miss Aura
May 18th, 2002
07:26:48 PM
Oops! Wheresa mesa manners? Excuse me, Master Obi-Wan. I complet
by Kiyone
May 18th, 2002
07:28:31 PM
Red Giant...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 18th, 2002
07:32:17 PM
The audience I was with laughed at yoda and booed when the movie
by metsrulein2k
May 18th, 2002
07:33:29 PM
I love hearing people say "If you didn't like this movie, yo
by Pongo
May 18th, 2002
07:33:52 PM
People who believe film looks better than digital :"A man convin
by Neutral_Density
May 18th, 2002
07:56:38 PM
my audiences loved it...
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
08:04:54 PM
Memo to all Jedi:
by Qwaz
May 18th, 2002
08:04:56 PM
"You're not a real fan!"
by Lidane
May 18th, 2002
08:06:00 PM
fluffygreycat, i agree!
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
08:09:52 PM
"You're not a real fan" is a bad argument, but...
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
08:15:01 PM
Lots of good and some bad
by ewem
May 18th, 2002
08:15:59 PM
7 Things Episode 2 Did Right
by Qwaz
May 18th, 2002
08:21:05 PM
1984!!!!!!!!!!!!
by XharbingerX
May 18th, 2002
08:24:10 PM
2 Points
by robertjconklin
May 18th, 2002
08:32:20 PM
Harry, you get it...
by Hoojib
May 18th, 2002
08:42:27 PM
Awesome post Qwaz!
by sparticusmaximus
May 18th, 2002
08:48:46 PM
Spider-Man came out Friday, idiot, Star Wars came out Thursday
by Drath
May 18th, 2002
09:14:51 PM
Its Star Wars and i love it....
by dazedlam
May 18th, 2002
09:25:06 PM
slobrow - he wasn't syfo dyas
by Reverend Rotund
May 18th, 2002
09:43:18 PM
Darth Vader never knew he *had* children!
by JTylor
May 18th, 2002
09:48:12 PM
AOTC RULES!...But
by ronnyron2000
May 18th, 2002
09:50:30 PM
AOTC RULES!...But
by ronnyron2000
May 18th, 2002
09:50:33 PM
Two Plot Holes as pertaining to Ep. 4
by sbisaacs
May 18th, 2002
09:51:07 PM
Kewl!
by Cap'n Chaos!
May 18th, 2002
09:51:17 PM
garbage
by PUNY HUMANS
May 18th, 2002
09:53:54 PM
RE: Darth Never Knew He Had Children?...
by ronnyron2000
May 18th, 2002
09:56:20 PM
RE: Dbsryyd; The Phantom Menace made over 431 million dollars
by Pongo
May 18th, 2002
09:57:10 PM
Saw it twice
by hornspe
May 18th, 2002
09:58:26 PM
Two Questions for yall........
by Floydof73
May 18th, 2002
10:08:26 PM
hey jirkoffs, I never said I started the booing the theatre (tha
by metsrulein2k
May 18th, 2002
10:09:03 PM
"Not a Star Wars Fan?"
by Bollux
May 18th, 2002
10:22:40 PM
My favorite phrase to watch for in a TalkBack:
by majorq007
May 18th, 2002
10:26:45 PM
Not a Star Wars fan...
by Flagg
May 18th, 2002
10:31:58 PM
I have a question...
by PAPERCUTS
May 18th, 2002
11:03:35 PM
AOTC was great, but critics, get the "sand" line right
by MaximUltra
May 18th, 2002
11:06:49 PM
Polarized your reactions are...
by GordonCOLE
May 18th, 2002
11:14:13 PM
Hey, MetsRule...
by Kikstad
May 18th, 2002
11:18:05 PM
idea
by alcester
May 18th, 2002
11:41:36 PM
like it or not...
by majorq007
May 19th, 2002
12:10:11 AM
Well said, OrionsAngel...
by majorq007
May 19th, 2002
12:12:11 AM
I have a question....
by OverMuch
May 19th, 2002
12:16:52 AM
It's all starting to come together
by Al2913
May 19th, 2002
12:23:20 AM
Overmuch:
by majorq007
May 19th, 2002
12:23:59 AM
we already know the ending
by dogfish112
May 19th, 2002
12:24:25 AM
or DID they mention them?
by majorq007
May 19th, 2002
12:25:42 AM
Thank you George....
by BatVomit
May 19th, 2002
12:25:58 AM
AotC may have answered the "no disappearance" of Qui gon thing S
by pajamo12
May 19th, 2002
12:28:48 AM
we already know the ending..
by dogfish112
May 19th, 2002
12:36:02 AM
movies that suck
by TreborSux
May 19th, 2002
12:50:14 AM
slaughtered lamb
by dogfish112
May 19th, 2002
12:55:50 AM
The Bitterness and Disappointment...
by RevZaius
May 19th, 2002
12:59:55 AM
How can you not like this movie?
by kxmode1
May 19th, 2002
01:04:51 AM
Ep II
by hmrags
May 19th, 2002
01:10:47 AM
Yay!
by Purple Toupee
May 19th, 2002
01:16:04 AM
If you doubt Hayden...
by kxmode1
May 19th, 2002
01:16:56 AM
Definate Flaws
by Maximus21
May 19th, 2002
01:19:15 AM
Dune
by Purple Toupee
May 19th, 2002
01:20:05 AM
Awesome
by lanfisher
May 19th, 2002
01:26:12 AM
thatsfdup
by holoholojoe
May 19th, 2002
01:26:33 AM
RE: thatsfdup
by kxmode1
May 19th, 2002
01:34:59 AM
The Cave
by lanfisher
May 19th, 2002
01:42:26 AM
A Different Viewpoint
by AltVoiceOne
May 19th, 2002
01:50:27 AM
I went in to the movie with the lowest expectations and...
by Butch_McTavish
May 19th, 2002
01:51:52 AM
Fuckiiiiing AWESOME!!
by wooLYaphid
May 19th, 2002
02:35:29 AM
Who Saw Triumph On Conan Last Night? OR... For Every 5,000,000 "
by jollydwarf
May 19th, 2002
02:40:02 AM
ATTACK O' Th' Clones
by Cody Stone
May 19th, 2002
02:44:37 AM
CAN'T WAIT OR Ep.III
by code_encrypted
May 19th, 2002
02:44:44 AM
Harry, great job! I'm very pleased with Star Wars Episode
by Tarl_Cabot
May 19th, 2002
02:50:12 AM
What he said...
by ArashiRyu
May 19th, 2002
03:00:40 AM
A Couple More Questions OR Some "Kid's Movie"!
by jollydwarf
May 19th, 2002
03:01:35 AM
OrionsAngel: digital movie screens and the wilhelm scream
by nverman
May 19th, 2002
03:08:41 AM
Some of us watch movies the way fat people eat junk food.
by Rael Trajan
May 19th, 2002
03:19:57 AM
To all you poor bastards who hated this film....HAA HAA!!! I enj
by Lezbo Milk
May 19th, 2002
03:21:54 AM
THE BEST THING ABOUT THE MOVIE WAS....
by billybobhoyle
May 19th, 2002
03:25:02 AM
Harry's questions
by Maggie
May 19th, 2002
04:10:48 AM
I DIDNT LIKE IT
by vekt0r
May 19th, 2002
04:16:06 AM
I DIDNT LIKE IT
by vekt0r
May 19th, 2002
04:20:07 AM
A Brilliant Film!
by Ismrain
May 19th, 2002
04:22:16 AM
More thoughts on AOTC...
by nverman
May 19th, 2002
04:30:19 AM
Why Make A big Deal Over The Movie Gross Of EP2 Or Spidy, and TH
by The Founder
May 19th, 2002
04:36:32 AM
What in the world am I reading here...Possible spoiler but at th
by Tozier
May 19th, 2002
04:39:52 AM
ATTACK OF THE CLONES!!!!! When was that then?
by MrSINISTER
May 19th, 2002
04:47:06 AM
addendum to my message
by Tozier
May 19th, 2002
04:50:57 AM
a shortcut??
by TheJ76
May 19th, 2002
04:54:09 AM
HARRYHAUSEN????
by MrSINISTER
May 19th, 2002
05:00:56 AM
thank you dbsryyd
by dogfish112
May 19th, 2002
05:15:01 AM
harry quoted wrong dialogue
by graymarch
May 19th, 2002
05:42:31 AM
sorry graymarch
by dogfish112
May 19th, 2002
05:44:16 AM
dialogue
by onscreen
May 19th, 2002
05:48:08 AM
Just a simple man trying to make my way in the universe
by nverman
May 19th, 2002
05:49:10 AM
Where is this bad pacing/editing i keep hearing about? COULD SO
by Sigue Sigue
May 19th, 2002
06:12:18 AM
This Englishman says 'God Bless America!'
by MrEnumber6
May 19th, 2002
06:12:42 AM
Oh well
by Atreides
May 19th, 2002
06:42:43 AM
For those of you that hate Star Wars........
by sithapprentice
May 19th, 2002
06:54:24 AM
For those of you that hate Star Wars........
by sithapprentice
May 19th, 2002
06:54:30 AM
It's All coming Together
by baronkarza
May 19th, 2002
06:55:37 AM
The fact remains, look closer, this picture has horrible screen
by marauderwd
May 19th, 2002
06:59:18 AM
Imperial March
by smurfherder
May 19th, 2002
07:07:08 AM

by Fight-clubber
May 19th, 2002
07:43:07 AM
Christopher Lee - LOTR & AOTC
by smurfherder
May 19th, 2002
07:44:33 AM
marauderwd
by nverman
May 19th, 2002
08:08:21 AM
Look at me!
by Corky St. Clair
May 19th, 2002
08:09:50 AM
Shade
by Sigue Sigue
May 19th, 2002
08:16:09 AM
wow, AOTC sucked
by Eternal
May 19th, 2002
08:51:42 AM
Eternal?
by deadend dropout
May 19th, 2002
09:02:35 AM
Horrible!
by FH
May 19th, 2002
09:12:32 AM
Finally got onto the board!
by Wicked Willow
May 19th, 2002
09:16:57 AM
"And for the record, Jedi sucked ass compared to both episodes i
by Eternal
May 19th, 2002
09:20:32 AM
Someone PLEASE answer these questions for me
by notageek
May 19th, 2002
09:29:38 AM
IF ONLY AOTC WERE EPISODE I!
by marcygo
May 19th, 2002
09:33:30 AM
I have had an Epiphany
by joshuavance1701
May 19th, 2002
09:41:16 AM
I give up on this talkback...
by Ernst Blofeld
May 19th, 2002
09:44:08 AM
Possibly the worst of the five so far
by abcdefz2
May 19th, 2002
09:51:18 AM
Maybe it's a kid's movie, but do kid's movies have t
by chiknfriedelfsac
May 19th, 2002
09:56:07 AM
TreborSux and others like him are buffons...
by vergence
May 19th, 2002
09:56:09 AM
joshuavance1701 -- sounds like your arguement is...
by vergence
May 19th, 2002
10:15:14 AM
hear, hear joshuavance
by km2000
May 19th, 2002
10:16:37 AM
Episode II
by nevada
May 19th, 2002
10:23:51 AM
Harry is Wrong!!!
by Damer1
May 19th, 2002
10:32:26 AM
BTW
by Damer1
May 19th, 2002
10:39:00 AM
Agree with Joshuavance
by Bizcrgi
May 19th, 2002
10:50:00 AM
Contacting Lucas
by Bizcrgi
May 19th, 2002
10:56:00 AM
Some Naysayers seem to be on a mission
by Kikstad
May 19th, 2002
11:11:43 AM
Everything is proceeding as planned
by kiwiUK
May 19th, 2002
11:16:35 AM
Is Jango dead?
by Elias4
May 19th, 2002
11:17:53 AM
just when i thought it couldn't get worse...
by robbiesincox
May 19th, 2002
11:27:28 AM
THE PROBLEM IS THIS.....
by MrSINISTER
May 19th, 2002
11:41:14 AM
Worst Episode ever.
by calvin hobbes
May 19th, 2002
11:43:20 AM
me hasnt seen it
by WOSSquee
May 19th, 2002
11:50:55 AM
joshuavance1701.....
by DCL2791
May 19th, 2002
11:58:44 AM
worst episode ever
by orson21
May 19th, 2002
12:05:54 PM
Elias4...
by EliCash
May 19th, 2002
12:06:38 PM
Do Geeks Fall in Love?
by Manci
May 19th, 2002
12:11:59 PM
Two Thumbs down
by BartMan
May 19th, 2002
12:15:44 PM
George Bores
by baldrick
May 19th, 2002
12:18:22 PM
Does Any One Know What Species Padme Is?????
by The Founder
May 19th, 2002
12:39:36 PM
It Looks Like Star Trek Will Be The Winner This Year!!!
by The Founder
May 19th, 2002
12:54:59 PM
AOTC is NOT a bad movie... but that doesnt make it a GOOD Star W
by Miramax_
May 19th, 2002
12:59:22 PM
crap by any other name...
by insidious
May 19th, 2002
01:06:51 PM
Enough
by sixroys
May 19th, 2002
01:31:15 PM
I'll tell ya why the love story seems unnatural...
by majorq007
May 19th, 2002
01:44:38 PM
sixroys
by Bizcrgi
May 19th, 2002
01:45:57 PM
HARRY: Why no review of the acting? Why no comments about the p
by Beaumont'sGhost
May 19th, 2002
01:50:09 PM
aotc is fantastic! the critics are so wrong its painful
by captain_pants
May 19th, 2002
01:50:19 PM
Contradicts Lucas...
by Miramax_
May 19th, 2002
01:54:40 PM
The magic of cinema...
by The Chameleon
May 19th, 2002
02:07:35 PM
AOTC in Perspective
by Bilbo
May 19th, 2002
02:13:01 PM
The geeks continue to bitch and moan, the real world continues t
by togmeister
May 19th, 2002
02:25:56 PM
What's wrong with the world?
by DarkFather
May 19th, 2002
02:27:14 PM
Disappointed
by BillFerny
May 19th, 2002
02:34:27 PM
Bad Historical Analogies
by Karla
May 19th, 2002
02:38:51 PM
If he was all that roled into one...
by Miramax_
May 19th, 2002
02:39:31 PM
There are only 3 haters, they just have several ID names each
by Movie Marty
May 19th, 2002
02:41:38 PM
Tozier
by Maggie
May 19th, 2002
02:46:58 PM
Orions Angel, people liked Spiderman for the characterizations a
by Arrogancy
May 19th, 2002
03:02:21 PM
Average - but will give it another chance
by Retrace
May 19th, 2002
03:02:26 PM
I love it and I hate it
by MrBabbage
May 19th, 2002
03:18:25 PM
DL That Friggin HILARIOUS Conan Insult Comic Dog Bit!
by MST3KPIMP
May 19th, 2002
03:21:50 PM
And while I'm at it...
by MrBabbage
May 19th, 2002
03:31:36 PM
Thank you George Lucas....
by BatVomit
May 19th, 2002
03:31:47 PM
Harry's review of Attack of the Clones
by bigdaddyD
May 19th, 2002
03:38:15 PM
Jollydwarf, sixroys, Guzman Fan and others who wish to talkback
by Silvio Dante
May 19th, 2002
03:49:10 PM
Lucas is a computer effects whore.
by LordDark
May 19th, 2002
03:52:01 PM
The Magic is BACK!
by pachanko
May 19th, 2002
04:02:47 PM
Does Jango lose his hand?
by Pageiv
May 19th, 2002
04:18:02 PM
what lucas says doesn't matter.
by majorq007
May 19th, 2002
04:27:10 PM
You know what's fascinating?
by Bollux
May 19th, 2002
04:38:59 PM
Talkback Wars: Episode II: Attack of the Fanboys
by Bad Guy
May 19th, 2002
04:39:20 PM
What to expect: EP III
by Clone One
May 19th, 2002
04:46:03 PM
The story is great! The film is not!
by mrlee
May 19th, 2002
04:49:10 PM
I'm just a simple fan trying to make his way through the uni
by AndyR
May 19th, 2002
04:50:16 PM
majorq007
by Miramax_
May 19th, 2002
04:52:31 PM
you people are pathetic
by TylersAndrew14
May 19th, 2002
05:33:12 PM
Clone One
by Silvio Dante
May 19th, 2002
05:34:00 PM
AOTC
by JEBBS
May 19th, 2002
05:35:32 PM
Underwhelmed anyone?
by malinky
May 19th, 2002
05:53:33 PM
I know who Darth Sy-Pha-Dias is!!!!
by zillabeast
May 19th, 2002
05:57:03 PM
AOTC 9 out of 10 rating
by gizmobrainyhead
May 19th, 2002
06:01:58 PM
AOTC versus TPM
by gizmobrainyhead
May 19th, 2002
06:05:35 PM
SHAGGINS
by Shaggins
May 19th, 2002
06:31:17 PM
It was "OK" [rife with spoilers, i'm sure]
by HeeHeeHee
May 19th, 2002
06:32:18 PM
SHAGGINS
by Shaggins
May 19th, 2002
06:36:05 PM
OK...I've figured out what annoyed me the most about AOTC...
by Lidane
May 19th, 2002
06:37:48 PM
Yoda NEEDS a cane to walk...
by badboymason
May 19th, 2002
06:54:24 PM
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> harry's right
by Lord Mall
May 19th, 2002
06:56:18 PM
Things That Need Resolved
by Hotmoon
May 19th, 2002
07:12:48 PM
My 2 Cents!
by Kelitor
May 19th, 2002
08:26:12 PM
Episode III spoiler......anakin redeemed
by 00rth0
May 19th, 2002
08:30:16 PM
How Padme Knew About the Hangar/Woke Up
by Barrow
May 19th, 2002
08:32:16 PM
Shade is a complete loser and should be banned from seeing movie
by Bluvoodoo2
May 19th, 2002
08:49:47 PM
The Dark Side of C3PO
by pachanko
May 19th, 2002
08:51:54 PM
Sorry, Harry, some of us DO get Episode 2
by Johnny Dagger
May 19th, 2002
08:57:47 PM
Kelitor should join Shade and never see movies again--and quit h
by Bluvoodoo2
May 19th, 2002
09:00:36 PM
I wonder which one will end up making more money...
by Pongo
May 19th, 2002
09:18:37 PM
I have my own petition idea
by Andy Andy
May 19th, 2002
09:34:46 PM
Tarkin designed the Death Star? DOH!
by billy_zardus
May 19th, 2002
09:39:18 PM
blah blah balh
by hockphooey
May 19th, 2002
09:43:50 PM
Oh man, maybe it's time I said what really needs to be said
by Butch_McTavish
May 19th, 2002
09:45:21 PM
uh, Dbsryyd
by The Tao of Joe
May 19th, 2002
09:59:34 PM
AOTC
by SoonerSean
May 19th, 2002
10:04:29 PM
Come on people, admit it... it sucked!
by TheGorilla
May 19th, 2002
10:47:16 PM
Wih all of the money spent here, can't GL hire a decent scri
by bepetey
May 19th, 2002
10:58:17 PM
This is getting pretty old people
by Al2913
May 19th, 2002
11:13:17 PM
JJB = LBJ????
by fonebone
May 19th, 2002
11:31:13 PM
"NewNivekJ1" just gave a perfect example of...
by Bollux
May 19th, 2002
11:36:10 PM
I'm glad you liked the movie, OrionsAngel; you've certa
by Butch_McTavish
May 19th, 2002
11:40:49 PM
The magic is gone
by Walkenhorst
May 19th, 2002
11:41:35 PM
I just saw it--yesterday, and today.
by Noriko Takaya
May 19th, 2002
11:59:22 PM
puppets
by johanner
May 20th, 2002
12:00:19 AM
Hey Andy Andy
by fladnaG
May 20th, 2002
12:13:41 AM
Vegas Pizza
by BillFerny
May 20th, 2002
12:19:31 AM
Star Trek in Star Wars: E2?
by darkknight_74
May 20th, 2002
12:29:01 AM
I can usually tolerate you guys who hate everything. I can even
by TheGinger Twit
May 20th, 2002
12:46:15 AM
gmaster, you idiot, AOTC had less per screen average than Spider
by Arrogancy
May 20th, 2002
01:05:29 AM
George needs a jester
by grinchgibbons
May 20th, 2002
01:06:09 AM
FIRE!!! OR... Go Read The Book 'Til You Can Disect The DVD
by jollydwarf
May 20th, 2002
01:09:02 AM
I DOUBT THAT THERE IS ANYONE WHO WHOULD BET THEIR LIFE ON SPIDER
by Shaggins
May 20th, 2002
01:49:15 AM
More Ep. III predictions
by hktelemacher
May 20th, 2002
02:46:01 AM
Expect Further Tweaks to Ep.4-6 (The Super-Duper Very Special Ed
by plzabuzme
May 20th, 2002
02:59:54 AM
Flying Artoo
by Darth Melkor
May 20th, 2002
03:20:55 AM
The Tao of Star Wars.
by Alquimista_24
May 20th, 2002
03:31:34 AM
DROIDS
by JACKYBOY
May 20th, 2002
03:43:03 AM
Huh?!
by yugdesrial
May 20th, 2002
03:43:34 AM
Romance
by smurfherder
May 20th, 2002
03:46:57 AM
re:yugdesrial
by Flagg
May 20th, 2002
03:47:47 AM
Re War Powers Act
by Karla
May 20th, 2002
03:48:13 AM
cult...
by Flagg
May 20th, 2002
03:49:18 AM
I think your Review was right on the money harry
by BigMattC
May 20th, 2002
03:56:15 AM
"Balance of the force"
by joshuavance1701
May 20th, 2002
03:58:23 AM
It's official, there's no pleasing you people. Sit out t
by Cruel Shoes
May 20th, 2002
04:49:40 AM
ALL YOU FAKE-ASS SPIDEY LOVIN-ASS GET
by rockbottom
May 20th, 2002
05:20:31 AM
i saw it two nights ago. i'm finally posting my opinions on
by a goonie
May 20th, 2002
05:57:30 AM
THE BEST COMEDY OF THE YEAR
by Parla
May 20th, 2002
06:02:32 AM
WankyBollocks said:
by cirhsein
May 20th, 2002
06:16:28 AM
Crappy romance & why did Yoda even need to rock? with some spoil
by ChuckHolland
May 20th, 2002
06:18:56 AM
It's Amazing that SW probably won't eclipse Spider-man&#
by MST3KPIMP
May 20th, 2002
06:26:28 AM
It's the beginning of the end for Star Wars.
by damo26
May 20th, 2002
07:49:16 AM
Why the whiners are whining
by biggabooty
May 20th, 2002
09:05:15 AM
A message to Kelitor...
by Hobbitastic
May 20th, 2002
09:15:02 AM
Bravo George and Company, great movie! I saw it for the second
by Z0D
May 20th, 2002
08:58:01 PM
No, it didn't suck totally as I feared
by NerdBird
May 20th, 2002
09:17:37 PM
Docloggins & Kelitor are certified dope heads...
by rockbottom
May 20th, 2002
09:17:37 PM
OrionsAngel
by Pongo
May 20th, 2002
09:31:51 PM
To All you Gloaters that Say Spiderman And Harry Potter Beat ATO
by TallScott
May 20th, 2002
09:35:25 PM
they'll never learn
by code_encrypted
May 20th, 2002
09:48:37 PM
Dead Jedis
by Ralph Wiggum
May 20th, 2002
09:49:58 PM
Just because it bares the Star Wars name...
by MissMiaWallace
May 20th, 2002
09:57:58 PM
Dare I say it and enrage an army of geeks....
by Virgil Sollozzo
May 20th, 2002
10:07:32 PM
okay, code
by Pageiv
May 20th, 2002
10:12:01 PM
Who here actually DOES go to a movie for good acting and screenw
by majorq007
May 20th, 2002
10:27:29 PM
Clones
by Darth Melkor
May 20th, 2002
10:28:29 PM
Shut the Fuck UP! ENJOY THE MOVIE!
by Drumbum
May 20th, 2002
10:51:14 PM
Box Office
by SoonerSean
May 20th, 2002
10:53:00 PM
Typos
by SoonerSean
May 20th, 2002
10:55:09 PM
...and I said ' You're Fucking A Right!'
by Billy Talent
May 20th, 2002
11:01:10 PM
Mediocrity
by Retrace
May 20th, 2002
11:08:11 PM
"Clones" goes head to head with "Empire"
by Flexfill
May 20th, 2002
11:25:47 PM
you people are crazy
by weati
May 20th, 2002
11:38:18 PM
to Rockbottom: eat my ass, you Clones-loving motherfucker!!!!!!
by a goonie
May 20th, 2002
11:39:01 PM
"AOTC", is BANTHA FODDER ! ! ! ! ! !
by luke_starkiller
May 20th, 2002
11:46:03 PM
Highfalutin - "dumb schmuck"? Oh, I so think not.
by Bollux
May 20th, 2002
11:53:38 PM
obviously someone who uses 'ass' and 'motherfucker&#
by majorq007
May 21st, 2002
12:03:03 AM
The Net Star OR... "Corona. They're on Corona."
by jollydwarf
May 21st, 2002
12:15:54 AM
AoTC was a mixed bag...
by chico-san
May 21st, 2002
12:25:17 AM
Trying to be the Voice of Reason
by shaps
May 21st, 2002
12:33:27 AM
Rank This!
by Zardoz
May 21st, 2002
12:49:33 AM
Somebody should make a movie titled: "Talkback Wars Ep I: The
by Z0D
May 21st, 2002
01:02:33 AM
A BIG disappointment...
by SoulOnIce
May 21st, 2002
01:19:14 AM
AOTC... sorry, I cannot reconcile this sloppiness.
by Nitestar
May 21st, 2002
01:25:35 AM
More terrible scenes
by Maximus21
May 21st, 2002
01:30:00 AM
I swore to that I wouldn't bother, but it can't be helpe
by Tozier
May 21st, 2002
01:33:08 AM
Star Wars
by DoubleD423
May 21st, 2002
02:12:30 AM
Scenes
by Darth Melkor
May 21st, 2002
02:15:15 AM
doc_loggins
by Sigue Sigue
May 21st, 2002
02:33:48 AM
doc_loggins needss to get a grip on reality and not so much on h
by BigMattC
May 21st, 2002
02:43:21 AM
Ep II... only just better than Ep I Otherwise Dire
by ENT IMP DOT COM
May 21st, 2002
02:47:52 AM
Im with The Vanisher...
by Flagg
May 21st, 2002
02:56:47 AM
If you didn't like, i suggest seeing it again
by Surn
May 21st, 2002
02:58:41 AM
rockbottom: Um, actually yes, Starship troopers DID have excepti
by Red Giant
May 21st, 2002
03:14:58 AM
why this movie was bad to the non star wars fanatic fan
by cannibuscrusader
May 21st, 2002
03:24:58 AM

by code_encrypted
May 21st, 2002
03:31:07 AM
you folks will never be satisfied
by Surn
May 21st, 2002
03:36:32 AM
That's me...Clones loving mutherfucker....
by rockbottom
May 21st, 2002
03:37:28 AM
An AOTC Fan Strikes Back
by PaulMrStarWars
May 21st, 2002
04:43:08 AM
No magic moments? Umm...
by EliCash
May 21st, 2002
05:06:31 AM
Dbsryyd.... I couldn't agree more.
by TheGinger Twit
May 21st, 2002
05:37:22 AM
Second Time 'Round...
by FatherMcGruder
May 21st, 2002
05:42:25 AM
25 REASONS WHY THIS FILM FAILS.
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
05:58:33 AM
25 REASONS WHY SPIDERMAN'S GROSS IS CLONES MONEY
by Shaggins
May 21st, 2002
06:05:41 AM
a short attempt to show the magic in context
by Surn
May 21st, 2002
06:14:25 AM
LUCAS AND AOTC HATERS: This ones for you!
by TallScott
May 21st, 2002
06:28:13 AM
The Galactic Disney.
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
06:39:40 AM
ILM DIGITALLY AGE EWAN AND IT'S THE TRUTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
07:26:50 AM
Not half bad...
by AliceInWonderlnd
May 21st, 2002
07:51:05 AM
To Alice...
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
07:58:07 AM
to all the naysayers
by ChuckHolland
May 21st, 2002
08:01:54 AM
MARK KERMODE WAS RIGHT.
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
08:06:45 AM
final numbers: 80M weekend, 110M 4 days
by minderbinder
May 21st, 2002
08:22:59 AM
And Alice wonders at the strangeness of her fate...
by AliceInWonderlnd
May 21st, 2002
08:31:13 AM
LISTEN,MORONS.....
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
08:35:00 AM
most interesting post ever
by earthworm777
May 21st, 2002
08:38:06 AM
SOMWHOW?????
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
08:40:00 AM
EPISODE THREE- How it all goes down [predictions]
by Clone One
May 21st, 2002
08:40:16 AM
the fact remains
by majorq007
May 21st, 2002
08:44:32 AM
AOTC fits right in
by DeWonderful
May 21st, 2002
08:50:34 AM
final word
by damo26
May 21st, 2002
09:02:57 AM
Damo 26 u r so right, Harry... What can I say.
by ENT IMP DOT COM
May 21st, 2002
08:35:05 PM
How many times does GL have to say it?
by Damer1
May 21st, 2002
09:29:50 PM
Feeling sorry for Vergence, I am
by TreborSux
May 21st, 2002
09:40:53 PM
Jango's sonic charges sound probs
by starmom
May 21st, 2002
11:51:36 PM
Attack of the clones, is actually a masterpiece.
by joshuavance1701
May 22nd, 2002
01:02:29 AM
AOTC
by Kalel
May 22nd, 2002
01:05:45 AM
For those who think that Yoda jumping around doing street fighte
by AntoniusBloc
May 22nd, 2002
01:08:10 AM
little gems
by TreborSux
May 22nd, 2002
01:30:57 AM
Highfalutin, either you missed my point...
by Bollux
May 22nd, 2002
01:32:53 AM
AOTC is Exceptional
by Mako
May 22nd, 2002
01:34:51 AM
Denial?
by hoorayforeric
May 22nd, 2002
01:44:10 AM
ONE MORE THING
by hoorayforeric
May 22nd, 2002
01:49:11 AM
Kelitor - BIG Difference Between TV and Film...
by Mako
May 22nd, 2002
01:58:55 AM
An Addendum
by joshuavance1701
May 22nd, 2002
02:28:38 AM
AOTC only made 110
by MST3KPIMP
May 22nd, 2002
02:46:36 AM
It's the old Jedi Mind Trick.
by hankaaron
May 22nd, 2002
02:47:36 AM
Did this happen to you?
by TreborSux
May 22nd, 2002
02:48:49 AM
jawas
by cheeky jawa
May 22nd, 2002
04:41:39 AM
to everyone who addressed a talkback to I (Doc_Loggins):
by a goonie
May 22nd, 2002
04:50:53 AM
NARRATIVE
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
04:53:13 AM
vdkhxjqv
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
04:59:15 AM

by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
05:04:13 AM
Here they come
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
05:07:40 AM
.................
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
05:08:13 AM
Why is it the haters have to post 20 times just to show how much
by TallScott
May 22nd, 2002
05:37:16 AM
Tall Scott
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
05:51:50 AM
Damo
by TallScott
May 22nd, 2002
05:59:14 AM
tall scott
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
06:10:38 AM
Belated spoutings
by Kaitain
May 22nd, 2002
06:23:41 AM
Sorry, that should have read
by Kaitain
May 22nd, 2002
06:28:33 AM
I'm not getting into this.
by Sepulchrave
May 22nd, 2002
06:29:14 AM
AOTC MUST BE BAD: LUCAS' WORDS, NOT MINE
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
06:43:40 AM
Damo, it's time to really give it up.
by ROMANWEB
May 22nd, 2002
07:47:05 AM
YOU COMPLETE F ***************!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by damo26
May 22nd, 2002
08:16:40 AM
Harry
by fxmulder35
May 22nd, 2002
08:47:30 AM
AOTC is more flawed than many will admit
by Darce24
May 22nd, 2002
08:49:18 AM
Final Clones review
by perndragon
May 22nd, 2002
09:01:37 AM
Please......
by ROMANWEB
May 22nd, 2002
09:04:02 AM
Damo Please......
by ROMANWEB
May 22nd, 2002
09:44:02 AM
Reply to Darth_Flagg (and George Lucas!)
by Darce24
May 22nd, 2002
09:55:34 AM
Better than TPM...but what isn't?
by ewem
May 22nd, 2002
06:53:43 PM
About digital projection...
by CoolDan989
May 22nd, 2002
09:36:09 PM
My opinion for what its worth
by EliCash
May 22nd, 2002
11:03:23 PM
fuckin people....
by clone my asshole
May 22nd, 2002
11:21:01 PM
To whoever said something like "(Great job Hayden!!!)"
by Pongo
May 23rd, 2002
12:29:16 AM
Rip-Offs
by fatzombie
May 23rd, 2002
01:39:26 AM
George
by Saviano
May 23rd, 2002
01:40:33 AM
I hear Lucas is gonna do some more tinkering. . .
by Noriko Takaya
May 23rd, 2002
01:51:47 AM
Harry is right...soooo right
by Jon E Cin
May 23rd, 2002
02:13:46 AM
I've said it before.....
by rb
May 23rd, 2002
04:52:21 AM
Damo finally retires: AOTC is not worth the effort.
by damo26
May 23rd, 2002
05:52:13 AM
I was dissapointed, unfortunately for me, but.....
by euphonium
May 23rd, 2002
05:53:33 AM
Sorry. As I was saying, but...
by euphonium
May 23rd, 2002
06:01:18 AM
To Harry
by rivermai
May 23rd, 2002
07:21:38 AM
I PITY ALL YOU LOSERS THAT DON'T LIKE AOTC
by EIFF
May 23rd, 2002
08:44:37 AM
Kelitor
by doctoru2
May 23rd, 2002
08:50:10 AM
It was really, shockingly bad.
by Monkey Handler
May 23rd, 2002
09:17:21 AM
More To Ponder
by KHBirdman
May 23rd, 2002
09:43:51 AM
Ian McDiarmid & Chris Lee underutilized
by Darce24
May 23rd, 2002
09:48:40 AM
The movie sucked, worst I ever saw.
by dmezei
May 23rd, 2002
09:52:23 AM
AOTC IS PURE MAGIC!!!
by hoorayforeric
May 23rd, 2002
09:55:42 AM
Where's Joe Hallenbeck?
by ewem
May 23rd, 2002
09:57:39 AM
Agreed, Kelitor.
by ewem
May 23rd, 2002
10:02:34 AM
please people
by forestlaw
May 23rd, 2002
11:32:37 AM
Great last hour!
by Knobules
May 23rd, 2002
11:40:23 AM
loved it
by udumbhonkysonofa
May 23rd, 2002
12:31:20 PM
It doesnt take a sheep to not love aotc or phantom menace..
by The Tao of Joe
May 23rd, 2002
04:51:03 PM
It doesnt take a sheep to not love aotc or phantom menace..
by The Tao of Joe
May 23rd, 2002
04:52:14 PM
There is no justification for AOTC
by jokrsmile
May 23rd, 2002
04:58:29 PM
no justification for AOTC
by jokrsmile
May 23rd, 2002
05:02:42 PM
AOTC is Star Wars
by Darth Melkor
May 23rd, 2002
05:03:13 PM
If I'd known it'd be this kind of party, I'd have st
by ARCTURUS
May 23rd, 2002
07:53:30 PM
Its just not very good
by tenko
May 23rd, 2002
08:22:03 PM
Senate Grants Bush Trade Power
by hankaaron
May 23rd, 2002
08:52:59 PM
You know, maybe it isn't that the movie "sucked"
by Jack Parsons
May 23rd, 2002
09:10:35 PM
A True Fan's sorrow
by redwheels
May 23rd, 2002
09:21:12 PM
The Day Star Wars Died!
by JarJar25
May 23rd, 2002
09:47:29 PM
You f'ng TR011$!
by Zone Zero
May 23rd, 2002
10:23:06 PM
the real problem
by Saviano
May 23rd, 2002
10:27:26 PM
badbadbadbadbad
by Vizzini
May 23rd, 2002
10:30:36 PM
Harry Seduced by Dork Side
by jpdanzig
May 23rd, 2002
10:50:06 PM
Pleasantly Surprised
by FrankCobretti
May 23rd, 2002
11:41:13 PM
A LITTLE SONG ON lotr TROLLING
by Virgil Sollozzo
May 24th, 2002
12:02:52 AM
The effects are better
by EliCash
May 24th, 2002
12:24:15 AM
Poops' thoughts on EPII and SW in general...
by PoopsMcGee
May 24th, 2002
12:34:31 AM
If this franchise was never made, none of you idiots would have
by Z0D
May 24th, 2002
12:35:51 AM
Yes it felt like a Star Wars Movie
by murph1016
May 24th, 2002
12:44:35 AM
Mannnnn
by nokknokk
May 24th, 2002
12:45:03 AM
Yes, Lamby, i will admit to coming off more than a little two-fa
by Virgil Sollozzo
May 24th, 2002
12:47:22 AM
in the above post, i meant to say "deeply ANTI-Star Wars"
by Virgil Sollozzo
May 24th, 2002
12:56:00 AM
the deal
by Saviano
May 24th, 2002
12:57:03 AM
My AOTC Review
by JediSean
May 24th, 2002
12:59:07 AM
With AOTC, George Finally Cast Off The Pretensions & Joseph Camp
by Buzz Maverik
May 24th, 2002
04:23:47 AM
YODA AND THE YOUNGLINGS is my favorite SW scene.......ever!
by sparticusmaximus
May 24th, 2002
04:27:02 AM
AOTC
by mig29
May 24th, 2002
08:20:46 AM
The one thing I would have changed about AOTC
by JediSean
May 24th, 2002
09:07:20 AM
What if....
by nokknokk
May 24th, 2002
10:12:46 AM
Wasted Opportunity
by FishEyedBob
May 24th, 2002
10:53:04 AM
Apologies for the language
by FishEyedBob
May 24th, 2002
10:56:34 AM
No apologia necessary Harry, just a review.
by rabid_republican
May 24th, 2002
11:33:41 AM
question
by blaktyga7
May 24th, 2002
12:16:27 PM
no justification for AOTC
by jokrsmile
May 24th, 2002
02:25:07 PM
Three Strikes and you're out...George
by blue meanie
May 24th, 2002
04:01:58 PM
Fan Boy Reviews
by WoodyStiffer
May 24th, 2002
04:51:39 PM
"Lucas is God"??? HAHAHAHAHA...
by Pongo
May 24th, 2002
07:03:10 PM
What?
by nokknokk
May 24th, 2002
07:04:33 PM
DLJFL
by nokknokk
May 24th, 2002
07:12:38 PM
Good Films - Have AOTC Fans ever seen one?
by WoodyStiffer
May 24th, 2002
08:15:45 PM
Hey JediSean, I agree with you on many things. I will love Star
by Z0D
May 25th, 2002
01:10:19 AM
A suggestion
by somethingclever
May 25th, 2002
02:20:38 AM
Lack of Visual awe
by Yossarian
May 25th, 2002
03:05:04 AM
even though i still chuckle (and cringe) at the "i pity you who
by a goonie
May 25th, 2002
03:35:23 AM
length of posts...
by tenko
May 25th, 2002
09:56:13 AM
length of posts...
by tenko
May 25th, 2002
09:59:20 AM
Must have hit pretty close to the mark to get him all riled up l
by vergence
May 25th, 2002
10:28:37 AM
Star Wars II, Good??
by joebuck77
May 25th, 2002
01:31:49 PM

by HellRide
May 25th, 2002
02:05:49 PM
What if Episodes 1 and 2 hit theaters first?
by ass clown
May 25th, 2002
07:22:21 PM
AOTC is terrible
by The Wiser
May 25th, 2002
11:48:05 PM
some sad news
by Saviano
May 26th, 2002
12:39:31 AM
some sad news
by Saviano
May 26th, 2002
12:43:04 AM

by Joshj
May 26th, 2002
12:43:22 AM
some sad news
by Saviano
May 26th, 2002
12:44:46 AM
some sad news
by Saviano
May 26th, 2002
12:45:28 AM

by Joshj
May 26th, 2002
01:09:07 AM
Please. I would never attack OT fans. I have great respect for
by TreborSux
May 26th, 2002
01:09:17 AM
some sad news
by Saviano
May 26th, 2002
01:16:03 AM
the movie rocked
by martinnyg
May 26th, 2002
04:05:51 AM
talk about lame
by afa
May 26th, 2002
07:45:22 AM
star bores: episode 2: attack of the crap
by megily
May 26th, 2002
10:50:07 AM
Oliver Stone and JFK
by Robertblood
May 26th, 2002
03:08:31 PM
see the movie twice? are you NUTS!
by MissMiaWallace
May 27th, 2002
12:17:37 AM
the sad news
by Saviano
May 27th, 2002
12:34:31 AM
Miss Mia Wallace
by WoodyStiffer
May 27th, 2002
02:59:44 AM
People who did not like AOTC, you don't speak for everyone..
by ROMANWEB
May 27th, 2002
01:14:16 PM
Give 'Em The RANCOR, George!
by lugnut
May 27th, 2002
02:34:00 PM
CGI Overkill and the sad fact that George Lucas doesn't give
by Jaimie Kanwar
May 27th, 2002
02:40:18 PM
Droids being recognized...
by Victor_Laszlo
May 27th, 2002
05:45:47 PM
To all of the little pukes bashing Clones
by juke171
May 28th, 2002
12:53:20 AM
How does a sonic mine work in space???
by stackpointer
May 28th, 2002
12:56:44 AM
Attack Of The Clowns
by stackpointer
May 28th, 2002
02:42:27 AM
haters need love too
by atomiceo
May 28th, 2002
04:41:56 AM
ANNAKINS DAD?
by KUBICK
May 28th, 2002
09:52:56 AM
This movie sucked!
by jokrsmile
May 28th, 2002
12:24:56 PM
I bent my wookiee
by AJRimmer
May 28th, 2002
03:13:02 PM
some holes explained and others pointed out
by bjtew
May 28th, 2002
04:00:35 PM

by homefry
May 28th, 2002
04:19:16 PM
Duck
by homefry
May 28th, 2002
04:38:03 PM
To Brian Jones and the other wannabeimportants
by Hoppleman
May 29th, 2002
03:00:30 AM
Where George Lucas got his SW2 inspiration from-Toy Stoy 2!
by Noell
May 29th, 2002
05:39:43 AM
I liked it!
by CaptainBitchway
May 29th, 2002
11:52:07 AM
Episode III Predictions
by Orc
May 29th, 2002
12:07:31 PM
Jeez!!!
by CaptainBitchway
May 29th, 2002
12:09:34 PM
Wow, the F-ing irony!
by Marvin_Monkey
May 29th, 2002
01:09:37 PM
Star Wars loses it's way back!!
by jokrsmile
May 29th, 2002
02:54:32 PM
All OF YOU.......SHUT UPPPP!!!!!!!
by Larry_Dallas
May 29th, 2002
03:50:24 PM
Lucas destroyed what the Saga is about
by Max Meanie
May 29th, 2002
04:02:55 PM
Lucas needs to give it up
by jokrsmile
May 29th, 2002
05:11:49 PM
AOTC is fantastic
by Jaster_Mereel
May 29th, 2002
05:12:25 PM
They could have added some stuff, though
by Jaster_Mereel
May 29th, 2002
05:23:12 PM
Max Meanie...I think you overlooked a few things or did what a l
by ROMANWEB
May 29th, 2002
06:07:16 PM
Some observations on racism in Star Wars, if anyone's intere
by samsquanch
May 29th, 2002
09:56:28 PM
Something interesting about the naysayers......
by Sigue Sigue
May 30th, 2002
01:46:11 AM
It sux! It ROXX!! IT SUX!!!! IT ROOOOOXXX!!!!!
by Noriko Takaya
May 30th, 2002
02:18:51 AM
I am a real fan of Star Wars.
by one9deuce
May 30th, 2002
02:57:43 AM
What I liked
by wackedfuck
May 30th, 2002
11:37:10 AM
It's the naysayers to the rescue
by jokrsmile
May 30th, 2002
04:32:30 PM
Darth Vader wants me...*SPOILERS*
by Namaalika
May 30th, 2002
11:05:17 PM
Exciting.
by Ragu
May 31st, 2002
02:04:29 AM
Fat and Stupid is not way to go through life son.
by Ruby Rue
May 31st, 2002
01:42:43 PM
Star Wars - The Whole thing from iv
by Chickenwire
May 31st, 2002
05:19:04 PM
read the whole thing before responding
by maelstrom218
May 31st, 2002
07:43:50 PM
Saw it today on a Digital DLP Screen
by superdavid
Jun 1st, 2002
12:52:47 AM
highly underwhelmed by the technology
by timgonmad
Jun 1st, 2002
04:04:03 AM
somebody please- lightsaber me
by dustable carnage
Jun 1st, 2002
05:23:23 PM
padme IS a jedi (like leia but doesn't know it)
by ev9dave9
Jun 1st, 2002
05:28:56 PM
I love it--Please LOTR fanboys keep it up.
by MJAYACE
Jun 1st, 2002
05:59:33 PM
to ROMANWEB and anyone who thinks "Clones" could've been bet
by Max Meanie
Jun 2nd, 2002
02:35:56 AM
Anakin
by ober0n
Jun 2nd, 2002
02:40:27 AM
Anakin
by ober0n
Jun 2nd, 2002
03:01:36 AM
Reply to MAX MEANIE
by ROMANWEB
Jun 2nd, 2002
03:46:24 PM
Oh, and by the way....
by ROMANWEB
Jun 2nd, 2002
03:56:53 PM
Well that's a few hours of my life I'll never get back..
by Spidey_88
Jun 2nd, 2002
04:41:08 PM
PLEASE GOD HIRE LAWRENCE KASDAN TO WRITE EP3!!!!
by JBigbooty
Jun 2nd, 2002
05:42:17 PM
"Attack of the Clones" dethroned at the box office...
by pedant
Jun 3rd, 2002
11:28:37 AM
STAR WARS is in trouble
by Batman_9
Jun 3rd, 2002
12:57:59 PM
Batman9 and whistling through the graveyard
by hildebrand
Jun 3rd, 2002
01:38:27 PM
re: hildebrand and batman_9
by pedant
Jun 3rd, 2002
02:39:13 PM
Forget Kasdan, there are plenty of others like the Matrix writer
by IT'SONLYAMOVIE
Jun 4th, 2002
12:08:55 AM
OK just seen AOTC, very impressed now
by Spab
Jun 4th, 2002
12:40:31 PM
the onion
by fonebone
Jun 5th, 2002
01:33:31 PM
Digital
by Damer1
Jun 5th, 2002
02:30:00 PM
May the Force be with you!
by mhmcclanahan
Jun 5th, 2002
04:34:37 PM
mhmcclanahan and acting
by hildebrand
Jun 6th, 2002
03:37:42 PM
see this film in dlp
by mavsman
Jun 6th, 2002
08:15:42 PM
How to get the most out of Clones...
by Tyler666
Jun 7th, 2002
05:08:57 AM
Obi Wan summed it up in 2 words, "Not Good"
by nvrtellmetheodds
Jun 7th, 2002
05:27:03 AM
Conan Dorks download that works. . . .
by superdavid
Jun 7th, 2002
10:21:31 AM
conclusion
by Sled-Head
Jun 7th, 2002
12:49:55 PM
Stop this negative bullshit!
by smitty1357
Jun 8th, 2002
04:31:25 PM
Number of Stars
by smitty1357
Jun 8th, 2002
04:42:51 PM
I think most of you are too stupid to enjoy this movie
by Sea Bass
Jun 8th, 2002
05:18:15 PM
Sea Bass
by hildebrand
Jun 8th, 2002
06:56:49 PM
SW Tech
by Serpent
Jun 9th, 2002
03:56:45 PM
history...
by 81666
Jun 9th, 2002
09:54:05 PM
Such a sad, sad waste .
by damo26
Jun 10th, 2002
06:11:37 AM
STAR WARS EPISODE 3 needs a great screenplay
by greenlightscafe
Jun 10th, 2002
07:27:40 AM
re: smitty1357
by pedant
Jun 10th, 2002
10:58:46 AM
Come on guys...you have to admit
by Batman_9
Jun 11th, 2002
02:16:50 PM
batman_9 and damning with faint praise
by hildebrand
Jun 11th, 2002
09:57:56 PM
Midichloriens (sp?)
by Willie139
Jun 11th, 2002
11:16:15 PM
Some major observations
by niftyneil
Jun 12th, 2002
11:49:28 AM
FUCKING PIECE OF DISAPPOINTING SHIT.
by damo26
Jun 13th, 2002
06:13:34 AM
Damo, it is time to LET it go!!
by ROMANWEB
Jun 13th, 2002
06:58:04 AM
Oh, and one more thing,
by ROMANWEB
Jun 13th, 2002
08:45:08 AM
sorry, I'm not actually Damo.
by damo26
Jun 13th, 2002
09:40:29 AM
Greenie, you're a meanie......
by ROMANWEB
Jun 13th, 2002
10:53:01 AM
David Prowse back in Vader suit for Episode III?
by Flexfill
Jun 13th, 2002
04:12:39 PM
Vader be Prowsed!,
by Tyler666
Jun 14th, 2002
05:51:45 AM
Just plain bad
by vastin_ardaen
Jun 14th, 2002
05:11:57 PM
This movie was cool/sucky.
by screenplaywriter
Jun 15th, 2002
12:48:42 PM
A few comments
by danaos77
Jun 16th, 2002
01:24:49 PM
Okay...
by SlicrSnipe1
Jun 16th, 2002
05:34:05 PM
yoda kicked ass
by goku son
Jun 19th, 2002
01:19:12 AM
I've waited to post....
by 20th Century Fox
Jun 19th, 2002
01:41:53 AM

by AurelianoBuendia
Jun 19th, 2002
06:48:17 AM
May the Force be With You
by AurelianoBuendia
Jun 19th, 2002
08:02:17 AM
One disappointed Star Wars fan
by Viper-GunClan
Jun 19th, 2002
05:16:31 PM
AOTC spells final death knell for magic of Star Wars
by mairead
Jun 20th, 2002
08:32:13 AM
FUCK DAMO26 AND ALL THE NAY-SAYERS
by damo26
Jun 20th, 2002
10:26:53 AM
Greenie is dead.
by damo26
Jun 21st, 2002
08:00:45 AM
Incontinentia Buttocks
by hgrumm
Jun 22nd, 2002
04:24:01 AM
I agree : The fat guy has really lost it
by damo26
Jun 22nd, 2002
10:00:33 AM
Final Film Review: EPII
by SilentMobius
Jun 24th, 2002
12:14:24 PM
Still haven't completely made my mind up
by Otto Parts
Jun 25th, 2002
12:29:29 PM
harry's review
by lorynnc
Jun 26th, 2002
12:38:07 PM
This is Star Wars
by T8H3X11
Jun 26th, 2002
01:02:37 PM
Star Wars Ep 2: AOTC
by The Highlander
Jun 27th, 2002
02:19:50 PM
My God, I don't think the word shit or bollocks is bad enoug
by The Highlander
Jun 27th, 2002
02:39:17 PM
Here's to all you nitpickers and naysayers!
by T8H3X11
Jun 27th, 2002
10:42:40 PM
Only one word can sum up the misery and terd they call Star Wars
by The Highlander
Jul 1st, 2002
01:58:08 PM
George's writing in SW ep1 & 2
by fnj006
Jul 2nd, 2002
02:05:14 AM
The PANTS they call Star Bores Ep 2
by The Highlander
Jul 2nd, 2002
07:57:08 AM
When are the haters going to realize?
by Azlam Orlandu
Jul 4th, 2002
06:05:46 AM
After seeing Clones for the fourth time I.......
by Mandolorian
Jul 4th, 2002
01:15:29 PM
Attack - Star wars at last!
by Zanoni
Jul 9th, 2002
03:43:35 PM
Attack of the clones
by jan
Jul 10th, 2002
04:59:01 PM
Episodes III and VIII Conections!!! + News that Sidious is actua
by javi13
Jul 14th, 2002
08:19:04 PM
Harry's right on the money with AOTC
by Yjimbo
Jul 15th, 2002
08:32:05 PM
How this trilogy could have been better...
by PoopsMcGee
Jul 20th, 2002
12:51:39 AM
Hayden not a good actor?!
by rocket13531
Jul 22nd, 2002
07:53:36 AM
My FINAL Thoughts
by Larry_Dallas
Jul 23rd, 2002
04:43:17 PM
Truly a sad devotion....
by kozmo
Jul 29th, 2002
06:58:31 PM
What's there to love - please explain
by kozmo
Aug 3rd, 2002
03:38:16 PM
In your age group? What is you age group? 12-18? Well you wanted
by matrix_sux
Aug 5th, 2002
10:58:02 AM
Koz, did you see the same movies as everyone else? As you might
by matrix_sux
Aug 5th, 2002
04:01:46 PM
romance?
by ylime
Aug 9th, 2002
07:57:01 AM
Eh...not as terrible as some people say, but not the greatest.
by Yufflez
Aug 10th, 2002
02:36:03 PM
JACKIE CHAN AND JET LI ARE DOING A MOVIE TOGETHER SCHEDULED FOR
by JP3183
Aug 15th, 2002
12:36:57 AM
DID SOMEBODY SPOT N'SYNC? I DID'NT...
by almato
Aug 17th, 2002
12:13:54 PM
Kozmo I received your email, If you wish to continue this dialog
by matrix_sux
Aug 22nd, 2002
10:07:52 AM
It's not a chick flick
by SyncMaster955
Sep 7th, 2002
12:21:44 AM
Fuck George Lucas and all his fanboy geeks right in their stupid
by Ronnie_Dobbs
Nov 12th, 2002
03:25:30 AM
Last!
by 2LeggedFreak
Dec 8th, 2002
11:29:28 AM

by macjazz
Jan 11th, 2003
07:30:40 PM
just had a casual DVD viewing
by Tall_Boy
Jan 17th, 2003
09:50:42 PM
Oh fuck you JOHNMALKOVICH
by matrix_sux
Jan 28th, 2003
01:33:25 PM
As a genuine, real life special effect
by neobido999
Feb 26th, 2004
08:47:58 PM
What the fuck are you talking about?
by matrix_sux
Oct 10th, 2004
10:21:14 PM
You've missed the point (as usual)
by bored stupid
Jun 20th, 2005
05:16:18 PM
Worst film ever
by Glyn
Aug 30th, 2006
05:15:54 AM
hello, friend.
by thebearovingian
Apr 27th, 2008
11:13:02 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.