Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Herc Gives FIREFLY 1.3 Four Stars!!

I am – Hercules!!

The last year has convinced me that I’m not a fan of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer.” I’m a fan of "Buffy" creator Joss Whedon, and whatever project captures his attention is the project that captures mine. Sorry if that sounds kinda gay. But I’m a 14-year-old girl, remember?

A mammoth fan of the original two-hour "Firefly pilot (which does not air tonight), I pity the fools who do not get to witness until December that pilot’s all-too-brief dinosaur fight; it only lasts about 20 seconds, but assures viewers they’re in good hands.

A few quick details about tonight's highly enjoyable outing.

* We learn the show is set in 2517.

* Despite some rumblings to the contrary, it looks like Fox sensibly decided to broadcast at least tonight's installment in letterbox.

* The Alliance infantrymen wear helmets that look suspiciously like the ones worn in "Starship Troopers."

* Joss Whedon not only co-wrote and directed tonight's episode, he wrote the music and lyrics for the fiddle-drenched opening theme.

* All the female regulars are beautiful, and the Adam Baldwin character gets a lot of the best lines.

* The prologue, spoken by series regular Ron Glass, is unclear about whether faster-than-light travel is being utilzed 500 years from now. The very first words we hear are: “After the earth was used up we found a new solar system and hundreds of new earths were terraformed and colonized. The central planets formed the alliance and decided all the planets had to join under their rule.” So this all takes place in one solar system with hundreds of planets? Neato!

* The "blue hands" business is cool and creepy. Herc can't wait to see what Team Whedon has in mind for the crazy psychic genius girl.

* The captain's final confrontation with his boss' henchmen is even funnier on film than it is on paper.

Herc’s rating for “Firefly” 1.3?

****

The Hercules T. Strong Rating System:

  • ***** better than we deserve
  • **** better than most motion pictures
  • *** actually worth your valuable time
  • ** as horrible as most stuff on TV
  • * makes you quietly pray for bulletins

8:00 p.m. Friday. Fox.

TV Guide says:

Negative buzz attached itself to Firefly after Fox asked Whedon to film a new first episode. But from what little we've seen, Firefly looks ambitious, provocative and original. Underestimate the gifted Whedon at your own peril.

Variety says:

Cheeky and charming, Joss Whedon's attempt to fuse oaters with "Star Trek" is just silly enough to work but there's plenty of B-movie attraction here to win over young Friday night viewers who have little else to choose from at 8:00. …"Firefly's" wide spectrum of characters is its greatest asset, since any of its ensemble could take center stage from week to week. Mal and Book seem to be the leaders, but that every personality trait is represented, from pouty to dangerous to intellectual, is a perfect way to hide some of its flaws (most notably a reliance on cartoon violence and ridiculously staged stunts that could have given way to more creative methods of larceny). … Whedon, who directed and co-wrote the debut, has also taken a page from "The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr." a years-old, short-lived series that likewise brought sarcasm and impudence to a genre that until then was strictly serious. "Firefly" has a lot of wink-wink dialogue, breezy acting and sexual chemistry that's never appeared in the science-fiction TV realm, and it's all executed by some very likable people.

The Hollywood Reporter says:

In a new season largely bereft of innovative ideas or daring concepts, "Firefly" stands out like a supermodel at a bus stop. In this, the first series by "Buffy" creator Joss Whedon under his development deal with Fox, he combines the sci-fi and Western formats, peppers them with wit and action and comes up with something truly original and highly watchable. … You might think it would be impossible to find an intersection between the high-tech world of sci-fi and the low-tech world of Westerns, but Whedon pulls it off. Mostly, he does this by avoiding the gaudier elements of sci-fi and creating a universe with a mixture of technologies, barren landscapes and an Asian influence.

I am – Hercules!!





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

it will suck oh yes
by soybomb2
Sep 20th, 2002
01:46:34 AM
Show and 14G.
by wiseoneredux
Sep 20th, 2002
01:49:35 AM
When One Takes Their Name From A Naked Guy Crashing A Dylan Set
by EricAlan69
Sep 20th, 2002
01:58:53 AM
Hooray for the god whedon!
by BRTick
Sep 20th, 2002
02:18:22 AM
I Can Also Write A Sentence And Capitalize The First Letter Of E
by arkhan77
Sep 20th, 2002
02:39:10 AM
This may turn out to be a decent show...
by Rick McCallum
Sep 20th, 2002
02:45:38 AM
Firefly
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 20th, 2002
03:10:32 AM
THIS SHOW IS A RIP OFF
by Feature
Sep 20th, 2002
03:22:14 AM
Feature
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 20th, 2002
03:32:55 AM
iF yOU wERE gOING tO dO tHE oPPISITE , iT wOULD lOOK lIKE tHIS..
by cozmicmonkeychow
Sep 20th, 2002
03:36:08 AM
you may be right
by soleis
Sep 20th, 2002
03:48:18 AM
I have no doubt this will be great...
by BermanSucks
Sep 20th, 2002
03:51:37 AM
Someone asked why Farscape fans think FF is ripping off well
by Spike fan
Sep 20th, 2002
04:31:41 AM
Herc says, for the record:
by Hercules
Sep 20th, 2002
05:29:29 AM
Rufus T. Firefly
by UTellEmSteveDave
Sep 20th, 2002
06:28:17 AM
They aren't real dinosaurs, they are freakin plastic. Downlo
by Maynard
Sep 20th, 2002
08:18:21 AM
SHUT THE PHUNK UP!!!
by RenoNevada2000
Sep 20th, 2002
08:43:43 AM
Yeah, Grover kicks ass.
by Regenhund
Sep 20th, 2002
09:25:47 AM
Finally, Firefly is here
by omarthesnake
Sep 20th, 2002
09:46:57 AM
Doesn't this thing have a title?
by 93curr
Sep 20th, 2002
10:25:34 AM
If this is ripped off from anything....
by stilettosmile
Sep 20th, 2002
10:56:25 AM
Firefly Titles
by LeeW
Sep 20th, 2002
11:10:14 AM
Did you know Joss Whedon has a penchant for anal sex?
by Cap'n Chaos!
Sep 20th, 2002
11:14:11 AM
FF is a ripoff of Starhunter
by You Are Banned
Sep 20th, 2002
11:14:37 AM
On the ripping off stuff...
by Cajun Lightning
Sep 20th, 2002
11:27:16 AM
Herc...we know you're not actually a 14 year old girl.
by Sod Off Baldric
Sep 20th, 2002
12:11:32 PM
Re: Rufus T. Firefly
by Kauzi Sezso
Sep 20th, 2002
12:42:56 PM
Blake's 7, of course
by GypsyTRobot
Sep 20th, 2002
12:46:51 PM
More on Ripping Off Stuff....
by Kauzi Sezso
Sep 20th, 2002
12:49:19 PM
Solar system with hundreds of planets?
by tbrosz
Sep 20th, 2002
01:11:55 PM

by NiteTime
Sep 20th, 2002
01:16:58 PM
Joss is going David Kelly.
by Christopher3
Sep 20th, 2002
03:42:55 PM
Just to reiterate...
by Cajun Lightning
Sep 20th, 2002
04:41:28 PM
On second thought...
by Cajun Lightning
Sep 20th, 2002
05:22:47 PM
FF
by Sofa King
Sep 20th, 2002
05:24:56 PM
Science in SF
by ChrisP
Sep 20th, 2002
05:45:54 PM
It's not an android in a suitcase...
by Kiyone
Sep 20th, 2002
05:48:12 PM
Some people call me a "Space Cowboy"...
by Kiyone
Sep 20th, 2002
05:53:00 PM
9 million space sagas
by GypsyTRobot
Sep 20th, 2002
06:06:51 PM
Firefly ripped off....
by PatrickY
Sep 20th, 2002
07:42:05 PM
CONFUSING!
by Skanky_Tony
Sep 20th, 2002
08:33:52 PM
Dayum!
by Fatty McJones
Sep 20th, 2002
08:39:07 PM
Really Off Topic...
by Skanky_Tony
Sep 20th, 2002
08:51:36 PM
hmmmm
by coop
Sep 20th, 2002
09:02:51 PM
Well this show....
by ComputerGuy68
Sep 20th, 2002
09:11:48 PM
People, people, people...If anything, a Cherryh ripoff!
by HillaryLovesMe
Sep 20th, 2002
09:14:59 PM
I thought it was great.
by Fatso
Sep 20th, 2002
09:16:13 PM
I liked it! nt
by mbeemer
Sep 20th, 2002
09:17:20 PM
fuck i missed it!
by yeah i'm a jerk!
Sep 20th, 2002
09:17:31 PM
Well, that sucked
by Sofa King
Sep 20th, 2002
09:22:52 PM
Oh, I should add
by Sofa King
Sep 20th, 2002
09:26:02 PM
A Great Show....little doubt that it will be canceled
by Number13
Sep 20th, 2002
09:26:42 PM
GREAT Show!
by Shadow_Duo
Sep 20th, 2002
09:26:47 PM
Sofa King and the Be-Bopers
by Shadow_Duo
Sep 20th, 2002
09:32:09 PM
Can I call it or what?
by Sofa King
Sep 20th, 2002
09:35:09 PM
semi off topic
by coop
Sep 20th, 2002
09:51:43 PM
Sorry, Sofa-Bitch, But I Have a Brain......
by Shadow_Duo
Sep 20th, 2002
09:53:16 PM
Wet my appetite
by DyslexicHeart
Sep 20th, 2002
10:11:53 PM
well... it was better than Buffy....
by 7ZeroCorpse
Sep 20th, 2002
10:13:33 PM
I wanted to like it BUT it was way weak.
by warlock411
Sep 20th, 2002
10:19:42 PM
Can I call it or what?
by Sofa King
Sep 20th, 2002
10:19:55 PM
The Only REAL Space Cowboy
by 7ZeroCorpse
Sep 20th, 2002
10:24:19 PM
I hate to admit it, but Sofa-King has a point...
by Electric_Monk
Sep 20th, 2002
11:06:59 PM
It didnt knock me off my feet but it didnt suck either
by alienmofo
Sep 20th, 2002
11:10:12 PM
I wasn't baiting anyone
by Sofa King
Sep 20th, 2002
11:13:48 PM
Mmm good, like Mmm cookies
by SallyHousecoat
Sep 20th, 2002
11:28:23 PM
Future air date?
by TheWarden
Sep 20th, 2002
11:32:01 PM
A REASONABLE answer to Sofa King & his ilk
by Prankster
Sep 20th, 2002
11:39:12 PM
"Now it's time for some 10 or 20 mindless Wedon fans to resp
by Electric_Monk
Sep 20th, 2002
11:45:37 PM
FF tonight
by ThingsThatTimDog
Sep 20th, 2002
11:54:04 PM
Should have let the 2 hour pilot air first-People at FOX are dum
by Anyawatcher
Sep 21st, 2002
12:03:10 AM
And SofaKing
by Anyawatcher
Sep 21st, 2002
12:08:26 AM
Wow, was it just me or did they make the space shots silent?!
by Drath
Sep 21st, 2002
12:15:17 AM
Good Show, Bad Science
by tbrosz
Sep 21st, 2002
12:27:46 AM
I thought it sucked.
by punto
Sep 21st, 2002
12:45:41 AM
Firefly
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
02:32:43 AM
"The last year has convinced me that I
by Mistah Kurtz
Sep 21st, 2002
02:45:26 AM
X-Files?
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
03:22:01 AM
It's obvious that ...
by SG7
Sep 21st, 2002
03:46:45 AM
yay!
by BRTick
Sep 21st, 2002
03:47:57 AM
yay
by BRTick
Sep 21st, 2002
03:49:07 AM
Yeah, Joss needs a sicence guy. Maybe some of the Futurama guys
by SG7
Sep 21st, 2002
03:52:49 AM
Drop the dippy hippy babble and the sarcasm and maybe it'll
by Son Of Batboy
Sep 21st, 2002
04:11:57 AM
Firefly vs 'Scape
by Spice-Orange
Sep 21st, 2002
04:42:25 AM
Firefly is toast
by Rick McCallum
Sep 21st, 2002
04:57:54 AM
more like fire-poo
by stormer313
Sep 21st, 2002
05:04:53 AM
umm....
by Hoof Hearted
Sep 21st, 2002
05:33:05 AM
when did you "battlestar galactica" bastard children suddenly be
by feverishkin
Sep 21st, 2002
05:38:46 AM
before anyone says
by feverishkin
Sep 21st, 2002
05:47:17 AM
Good Show - Great Theme
by KingOfCrows
Sep 21st, 2002
06:55:40 AM
Oh... One more thing kiddies
by KingOfCrows
Sep 21st, 2002
06:58:52 AM
Never Seen Buffy
by EvilStar
Sep 21st, 2002
07:20:35 AM
Variety
by chani
Sep 21st, 2002
08:17:19 AM
well, I don't think it was a ripoff
by Moose of Heaven
Sep 21st, 2002
09:11:21 AM
EvilStar
by YourOlympicHero
Sep 21st, 2002
09:45:27 AM
So, the reaction here is mixed.
by Drath
Sep 21st, 2002
10:18:02 AM
A Space Western: Buzz and Woody would be proud.
by Xocxoc
Sep 21st, 2002
10:50:38 AM
SORRY but...
by Kort Villikon
Sep 21st, 2002
10:52:27 AM
For the record...
by Zubalove
Sep 21st, 2002
11:00:30 AM
Prankster
by Sofa King
Sep 21st, 2002
11:30:03 AM
Sofa King's entitled to his opinion (even if I think he'
by Voice O. Reason
Sep 21st, 2002
11:31:56 AM
"Were there monkeys?"
by KittyFantastico
Sep 21st, 2002
12:03:26 PM
about the ending...
by Sofa King
Sep 21st, 2002
12:11:00 PM
Ratings from Friday Night
by Total Geekazoid
Sep 21st, 2002
02:01:25 PM
Firefly will last one season
by RoobyRoo
Sep 21st, 2002
02:03:19 PM
Sofa King, about the ending...
by Voice O. Reason
Sep 21st, 2002
02:05:54 PM
Comparing FireFly to its predesessors
by mildlyobsessed
Sep 21st, 2002
03:20:27 PM
Doesn't look like a winner
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Sep 21st, 2002
04:02:29 PM
why the FF didn't seem great
by buffyluvr2k2
Sep 21st, 2002
05:13:00 PM
Kinda dull...
by Christopher3
Sep 21st, 2002
05:14:59 PM
You protest too mucn, I think.
by Hoof Hearted
Sep 21st, 2002
06:05:32 PM
Holy crap
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
06:11:22 PM
Holy crap
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
06:11:35 PM
Holy crap
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
06:11:59 PM
oops
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
06:12:57 PM
Simply as this.....
by YaGottaBeKidding
Sep 21st, 2002
06:42:38 PM
Set in 2517? As in Ezekiel 25:17?
by Morty Viventi
Sep 21st, 2002
08:57:42 PM
Thought the opening theme was a bit lame
by Geekgrrl
Sep 21st, 2002
09:00:22 PM
Oh yes of course....
by Sofa King
Sep 21st, 2002
09:13:28 PM
Firefly has potential. May someday even rival DS9.
by brattain
Sep 21st, 2002
09:16:32 PM
FOX network suits are PATHETIC LOSERS
by TheEqualizer
Sep 21st, 2002
09:25:15 PM
just did'nt hold my interest.
by Oompacabra
Sep 21st, 2002
09:27:11 PM
sofa king
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
09:30:27 PM
Tech advances only 20 years?
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
09:38:17 PM
Qwerty Uiop
by Sofa King
Sep 21st, 2002
10:23:22 PM
Hey, the Klingon Bird of Prey had wings, too!
by Voice O. Reason
Sep 21st, 2002
10:36:27 PM
well,
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 21st, 2002
10:55:14 PM
I dunno...
by AlphaAlfa
Sep 21st, 2002
11:00:40 PM
One thing this show has going for it
by warlock411
Sep 21st, 2002
11:03:09 PM
Nothing wrong with 'ripping off' & Disney's other si
by turk128
Sep 22nd, 2002
02:14:54 AM
except...a hybrid car doesn't fly. :)
by The Killer-Goat
Sep 22nd, 2002
02:47:53 AM
Accuracy is important, and quite easy, Pulp Dusk.
by tbrosz
Sep 22nd, 2002
03:04:10 AM
The Perfect Solution (tm)
by 7ZeroCorpse
Sep 22nd, 2002
03:19:26 AM
We aren't getting anywhere in this TB... as usual.
by Spice-Orange
Sep 22nd, 2002
04:07:29 AM
In response to above: bad guys...
by Spice-Orange
Sep 22nd, 2002
04:31:25 AM
Buffy vs Drama
by Spice-Orange
Sep 22nd, 2002
04:49:55 AM
Holy crap, its early
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
04:55:19 AM
Listen up, science "purists"
by Lily Drop
Sep 22nd, 2002
04:55:32 AM
Spice Orange
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
04:59:10 AM
Hey!
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
05:06:58 AM
Bad guys gone good, the cliche
by Lily Drop
Sep 22nd, 2002
05:11:32 AM
Hey's for horses, pulp_dusk
by Lily Drop
Sep 22nd, 2002
05:19:18 AM
OPPS! I meant, "Hey's for horses, Qwerty Uiop"!
by Lily Drop
Sep 22nd, 2002
05:22:40 AM
one more post from me, yay!
by Spice-Orange
Sep 22nd, 2002
05:29:24 AM
I'm on the side with butter on it, baby.
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
05:40:57 AM
Wolrds, not planets
by bjmc1975
Sep 22nd, 2002
09:22:50 AM
Okay, show of hands...
by Voice O. Reason
Sep 22nd, 2002
11:29:04 AM
2 stars at the most & why are there posts about farscape here?
by mgalloway
Sep 22nd, 2002
12:11:21 PM
Lily Drop
by coop
Sep 22nd, 2002
12:32:07 PM
Scientific accuracy and stupid plotting
by Sofa King
Sep 22nd, 2002
01:33:55 PM
The "one system" thing
by Spatzimaus
Sep 22nd, 2002
01:36:10 PM
Sofa King
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
02:28:23 PM
You wouldn't know thinking if it smacked you in the ass
by Sofa King
Sep 22nd, 2002
02:40:22 PM
Are you making a pass at me?
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
02:52:54 PM
Musings on Sofa King
by Hoof Hearted
Sep 22nd, 2002
06:32:31 PM
Firefly, whata dim bulb
by ama177823
Sep 22nd, 2002
07:18:15 PM
holy repeat, Batman!
by Hoof Hearted
Sep 22nd, 2002
07:50:24 PM
I'll be damned.
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
07:55:25 PM
Remember when the Farscape characters were shrunk, and one compl
by Drath
Sep 22nd, 2002
09:13:17 PM
"Losers in Space"
by Darth Ebert
Sep 22nd, 2002
09:55:03 PM
wow
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 22nd, 2002
10:10:47 PM
Firefly? No thank you.
by Johnny Dagger
Sep 22nd, 2002
10:40:20 PM
Sorry to disagree with you, Herc, and anyone else who liked this
by WarDog
Sep 22nd, 2002
11:46:54 PM
UNDERWHELMING
by DredPirateMethos
Sep 23rd, 2002
12:06:42 AM
laugh my ass off
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 23rd, 2002
12:08:11 AM
Pulp_dusk and Dark Angel
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 23rd, 2002
12:12:59 AM
Just to prove I'm a fair minded man...
by Voice O. Reason
Sep 23rd, 2002
12:30:16 AM
Voice O. Reason
by Fluxmaster
Sep 23rd, 2002
01:40:47 AM
Coop... If the term "solar system" is OK with NASA, it's OK
by Lily Drop
Sep 23rd, 2002
01:45:55 AM
History.
by Qwerty Uiop
Sep 23rd, 2002
03:14:01 AM
OK, not great, not bad
by GypsyTRobot
Sep 23rd, 2002
10:46:40 AM
lively feedback!
by omarthesnake
Sep 23rd, 2002
03:58:05 PM
Word, Qwerty Uiop.
by Voice O. Reason
Sep 23rd, 2002
04:57:58 PM
Relax guys, it's just a tv show
by Piccolo Daimao
Sep 23rd, 2002
06:16:23 PM
Herc and all the tv critics are smokin' the same crack
by Halloween68
Sep 23rd, 2002
09:13:00 PM
I really hate to say it...
by goldkngt55
Sep 24th, 2002
09:34:18 AM
I asked,
by Hoof Hearted
Sep 25th, 2002
02:26:47 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.