Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Hercules Quite Likes The First STAR TREK Of Sweeps!!

Star Trek: Enterprise 3.8 FAQ

A “Star Trek: Enterprise” review? When was the last time Coax kicked in one of these?

We appraised the third-season premiere. Way back when this show was still called “Enterprise.”

What’s tonight’s called?

“Twilight.”

Who’s responsible?

Teleplay is credited to Mike Sussman (“Dead Stop,” “The Catwalk,” “Future Tense,” “Regeneration,” “Anomaly”).

What does TV Guide say?

“Archer suffers a puzzling form of amnesia that distorts his long-term memories. He is further confused to find himself in the future aboard an Enterprise commanded by T'Pol. Ambassador Soval: Gary Graham. Yedrin Koss: Brett Rickaby.”

What is TV Guide not telling us?

T’Pol’s screen time in command – and in that blue Starfleet jumpsuit – is limited, but this is still very much her episode.

The big news?

This is by far the best installment of the series we’ve seen this season.

The far bigger news?

The Xindi reduce the planet Earth to perhaps 45 fiery, equally sized and wholly uninhabitable chunks. Then the Xindi begin hunting down the fewer than 6,000 human beings who survive the cataclysm.

Is this a hoax, a dream, or an imaginary episode?

No! It all really happens!

How does T’Pol find herself in command at all?

While freeing T’Pol from a collapsed bulkhead, Archer’s brain is subjected to an anomaly that deposits parasites that “exist outside time and space.” Because of these parasites, Archer goes all “Memento,” unable to create any long-term memories. Each morning, for more than a decade, he remembers nothing before the mishap. T’Pol has to assume command. But as the first act begins, T’Pol is no longer captain, her hair is very long, and Archer’s is very grey.

What’s good?

The scope, the drama, the pacing and the structure. By presenting us with a depiction of mankind’s final days, we are provided for the first time with a very real sense of what is at stake in this bizarre conflict with the Xindi. I found myself a bit moved by the evolution of T’Pol’s regard for Archer (Jolene Blalock brings much to the table this week), and I was keen to learn how the powers-that-be were going to dig themselves out of this fascinating narrative hole - and I was not disappointed with the denouement. This episode cribs shamelessly from one of Herc’s favorite Voyager stories, “A Year in Hell” - to say nothing of “Yesterday’s Enterprise,” “All Good Things…” “First Contact,” “The City on the Edge of Forever” and “Endgame” - but these are great stories, and this one remained just different enough for me to kind of love it.

What’s not so good?

Bakula seems like a good guy, and does a serviceable job this week, he’s still no Shatner. Or Stewart. Or Brooks. Or McKellen. And they’re sticking with that horrible theme song. (Quick thinking with that!)

Why so few spoilers, O Hercules?

The fun is in the revelations. And the hairstyles. And the facial hair.

How does it end, spoiler-boy?

T’Pol shoots her superior a vaguely suspicious glance.

Herc’s rating for “Enterprise” 3.8?

****

The Hercules T. Strong Rating System:

  • ***** better than we deserve
  • **** better than most motion pictures
  • *** actually worth your valuable time
  • ** as horrible as most stuff on TV
  • * makes you quietly pray for bulletins

9 p.m. Wednesday. UPN.

I am – Hercules!!





Looking for bumper stickers, plush toys and girls’ underwear covered with cartoon double-amputees? Visit The Herc Store!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

first
by vash001
Nov 5th, 2003
01:10:09 AM
song!
by Danger Mouse
Nov 5th, 2003
01:40:18 AM
In the words of my former colleague, "Mr. Stinky Pants"...
by Captain Decker
Nov 5th, 2003
02:07:45 AM
McKellen?
by Don Lockwood
Nov 5th, 2003
02:10:08 AM
People still watchin this shit?
by RightNutofGod
Nov 5th, 2003
02:30:20 AM
Berman?
by CMBat
Nov 5th, 2003
02:40:55 AM
what the?
by SmutGirl
Nov 5th, 2003
07:28:31 AM
Odd Seasons of Trek Are Good Rule?
by warp11
Nov 5th, 2003
08:26:23 AM
Come off it Warp11...
by rev_skarekroe
Nov 5th, 2003
08:55:43 AM
theme song solution
by Lon Bowling
Nov 5th, 2003
09:32:26 AM
Dammit, you mean they use the RESET BUTTON AGAIN!
by Drath
Nov 5th, 2003
09:57:13 AM
Give Trek to Sussman
by themikejonas
Nov 5th, 2003
10:09:08 AM
Enterprise
by CTM1975
Nov 5th, 2003
10:09:34 AM
Year of Hell...not Season
by Ninja Nerd
Nov 5th, 2003
02:57:15 PM
Year of Hell...not Season
by Ninja Nerd
Nov 5th, 2003
02:58:04 PM
Re: CTM
by themikejonas
Nov 5th, 2003
07:28:07 PM
Thank God Star Trek's finally gotten the balls to tackle time tr
by yneway
Nov 5th, 2003
07:41:52 PM
Seti Alpha V, Mutara Sector....hmmmm
by ZocaloHobo
Nov 5th, 2003
08:27:28 PM
"A Season in Hell" is one of your favorite episodes, Herc?
by MyNameDoesn'tFit
Nov 5th, 2003
08:32:38 PM
BY FAR the best Enterprise episode to date.
by symphy
Nov 5th, 2003
08:58:27 PM
*sigh*
by symphy
Nov 5th, 2003
09:00:48 PM
Excellent spisode, ENT needs more of these!!!
by ZocaloHobo
Nov 5th, 2003
09:14:34 PM
About freakin' time...
by Leopardghost
Nov 5th, 2003
09:32:54 PM
Very good episode. Theme song still induces vomiting.
by Eyegore
Nov 5th, 2003
10:28:21 PM
if you didn't like this episode you know fuck all about science
by Tall_Boy
Nov 5th, 2003
11:37:39 PM
Please Tell Me Next Week is Not a Western...
by JohnnyBravo
Nov 6th, 2003
01:35:20 AM
Good episode?
by RoboBagPiper
Nov 6th, 2003
07:51:25 AM
Borg
by jtp8000
Nov 6th, 2003
09:55:18 AM
It did work better than I feared
by Drath
Nov 6th, 2003
11:05:04 AM
cutest and Orion'sAngel....
by MisterGrimloch
Nov 6th, 2003
11:55:50 AM
I'm all for using plot devices like the reset button
by durhay
Nov 6th, 2003
12:22:38 PM
Season in Hell...
by farquar
Nov 6th, 2003
01:18:56 PM
This was the 1st episode of Enterprise I've seen...
by buckna
Nov 6th, 2003
01:41:21 PM
Oh yeah Cutest...
by buckna
Nov 6th, 2003
01:48:00 PM
admitted curiosity....
by MisterGrimloch
Nov 6th, 2003
03:42:54 PM
thats "know", not "no"...
by MisterGrimloch
Nov 6th, 2003
06:54:46 PM
Wasn't bad.
by Sith Lord Sauron
Nov 6th, 2003
09:02:33 PM
For those remotely defending garbage like Babylon 5, please, for
by alexr
Nov 6th, 2003
11:13:30 PM
Grimloch
by buckna
Nov 6th, 2003
11:38:21 PM
ST vs B5
by Real Deal
Nov 6th, 2003
11:40:18 PM
alexr
by buckna
Nov 6th, 2003
11:50:04 PM
I refuse to get into the dumb-ass "B5 vs DS9" flamewar.
by Sith Lord Sauron
Nov 7th, 2003
02:21:33 AM
buckna, alexr, RealDeal, SithLordSauron..
by MisterGrimloch
Nov 7th, 2003
08:14:51 AM
ok LoCutest of Borg.....
by MisterGrimloch
Nov 7th, 2003
02:41:46 PM
Got Time anamoly Issues WRONG again, as always
by No-Op
Nov 7th, 2003
03:08:35 PM
For all you B5 hatas...
by Mad_Radhu
Nov 7th, 2003
08:05:40 PM
Oh, I wasn't flaming, MisterGrim--
by Sith Lord Sauron
Nov 7th, 2003
09:27:49 PM
JS
by Real Deal
Nov 7th, 2003
11:33:17 PM
JS
by Real Deal
Nov 7th, 2003
11:36:20 PM
Enterprise, not the turd you self-righteous cynics think
by parnellbc
Nov 8th, 2003
01:49:44 PM
Jack Shit
by DMented
Nov 10th, 2003
01:45:47 PM
Re: Theme Song
by DMented
Nov 10th, 2003
05:34:32 PM
missed first 5 minutes...
by righteousdude
Nov 10th, 2003
05:42:38 PM
Trek
by cooper2000
Nov 10th, 2003
08:16:30 PM
RE: Captain Sulu series
by AICN fanboy dork
Nov 10th, 2003
10:50:50 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.