Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

First Review of a Test Screening of TROY - Sounds Utterly Fantastic!

Hey folks, Harry here... well here we go, one of the biggies... Seems Warner Brothers actually did a test screening of TROY on Thursday night, and it sounds like... at this stage, it is a helluva movie. Sounds very hard R. Will Warners and Robinov have the backbone to let Wolfgang keep the film at this level, or will they sanitize it, sandblast it and generally make the film limp and flaccid? Let us hope something close to what Bonk of 37 here saw is what we get this May. Let's hope that others at the screening felt the same way and maybe Warners will actually give us a great film this Summer!!! Here's hoping!

TROY review  

Hey Harry, the Bonk of 37 here with a review of the first screened cut of TROY, the new Wolfgang Peterson film scheduled for release on May 14. The long and short of it before I get down to the meat and potatoes is that the Warner execs were aiming for PG-13 Gladiator, and in the end they made a heck of a good movie. I really really liked it.  

The cut they showed was said to be the very first shown to audiences. The special effects weren't finished, and the music was from Starship Troopers and Pearl Harbor. This cut was three hours long, but what will be released will more than likely be 2h15 to 2h30 minutes long. Three Warner execs and Wolfgang Peterson were there, so that made it even cooler.  

Here's the story, so there are some minor spoilers ahead, but to anyone familiar with Homer's The Iliad, this is nothing new. On the verge of peace, Hector and Paris of Troy (Eric Bana from Hulk and Orlando Bloom a.k.a. Legolas) celebrate with new friend the King of Sparta (Brendan Gleeson from Lake Placid, Cold Mountain, etc.). Paris is a stupid little pretty boy who decides to sleep with and steal away the Spartan King's wife, Helen (the very yummy and super duper delicious hottie Diane Kruger), and return to Troy with Helen as his tasty treat of a girlfriend. Naturally, jealousy and hatred ensue.  

Well, mostly all-out pissed rage and bloody, violent combat than jealousy and hatred. The King of Spartan's brother is conqueror Agmemnon (brutish and commanding Brian Cox, great as ever), who has "united" the kingdoms and armies of Greece through diplomacy and battles. He has always wanted Troy to fall under his power, so he has his best warrior Achilles (Brad Pitt) and all his armies sent to Troy to take back Helen and rule Troy by force.  

My initial reaction to Troy was much like how I reacted to The House of Sand and Fog. Both sides are portrayed fully, the "good" side of Troy and the "bad" side of Sparta, so that neither truly seems like the good or bad guys, or the "right" or "true" victors. Both sides are right and both are wrong, but in turn it makes it difficult to root for or against any particular character, with few exceptions. First, Eric Bana. Don't let the advertising fool you, this is his movie. His character of Hector is a great man, brave and scared, strong willed and determined but realistic, the most realized and well written character. He is known now, but this movie will make him a star. Second is Brian Cox. Boy, what an asshole of a character. A scenery-chewing, screaming tyrant. And he looks good with long hair, surprisingly.  

The third is Achilles. Brad Pitt is not necessarily the main character of the movie. He is in it as much as the others, and has a less developed character. He is Darth Maul with a conscious, a super badass with tunnel vision. He has one scene of wisdom, one of fucking, one of emotion, and the rest is all badass super fighting. But when he fights, he kicks some serious ass. Whew! Imagine Neo not fighting like a pussy in Matrix Reloaded and actually using a sword to stab people and you have an idea. And the coolest part? Very little reliance on computer effects and editing that doesn't give you a headache. His fights are  wonderfully choreographed and incredibly fast. To reiterate: He kicks serious ass. That boy can fight.  

Speaking of fighting...remember how Warner said they wanted PG-13? Well, there is no way in hell this movie is PG-13, with all of the spurting blood, staffs through the head, stabbings, hangings, and all around bloody fighting, not to mention the pubic revelations of both Pitt and Orlando Bloom and the sweet, sweet, amazingly scrumptious, yummy yummy yummy tits and ass of Diane Jruger....hot damn! That girl looks good naked! Anyway, there will be some major trimming if they don't expect the R rating.  

Oh, and about Legolas...yeah, he is entirely pointless. Ignore the third billing. Aside from setting the story in motion in the beginning, Bloom is hardly in the movie. He serves no purpose. He is set dressing at the least and a plot devise at the best. Twice in the film his actions set up the storyline for the other characters but leave him with nothing to do. It is a thankless role. In fact, his character and relationship with the the other characters in the film is its biggest fault. Hopefully they'll trim a bit of him from the movie. Him, and the whiny little brat who plays Achilles' cousin and essentially creates the reason Achilles fights the Trojans. You know how it works, the same thing that's been done to death before: younger character idolizes older stronger character, picks a fight, comes back dead, and viola! Motivation and emotional response for the lead character.)  

Despite the sweet Helen of Troy tit shot and heavy violence, it's the subtlety in Eric Bana's performance and the quiet moments of Achilles in thought or talking with the royal priestess that make the movie that much more enjoyable. These types of moments keep the movie from entering the pool of recent military movies that substitute battles in place of storyline, a la Black Hawk Down, Tears of the Sun, or We Were Soldiers.  

Last but not least, Peter O'Toole still rules. The look on his face when he sees the size of the Spartan army marching on Troy...classic. Truly classic.  

Overall, a damn good movie. I can't wait to see it with finished effects and music that fits better. And here's to hoping those brutal fight scenes and sweet ass titties stay in the picture. :-)  

Call me Bonk of 37.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

First!!
by HOB
Feb 13th, 2004
03:29:53 AM
I think they should make Troy 2: the Broken Condom with Hulk Hog
by HOB
Feb 13th, 2004
03:31:08 AM
Please please please
by Stormin
Feb 13th, 2004
03:31:10 AM
This film...
by Effigy2002
Feb 13th, 2004
03:34:45 AM
Pubic Revelations of Pitt & Bloom?
by Wesley Snipes
Feb 13th, 2004
03:36:06 AM
SEVENTH!
by Sledgeh101
Feb 13th, 2004
03:37:26 AM
Sounds like a damn good movie.
by Psyclops
Feb 13th, 2004
03:56:49 AM
Liam Neeson as Ra's Al Ghul
by willscarlet
Feb 13th, 2004
04:30:06 AM
Well, there's some good news. :)
by raw_bean
Feb 13th, 2004
04:34:15 AM
I was *so* worried about this movie...
by Swithin
Feb 13th, 2004
04:45:57 AM
Been saying this for quite some time: ERIC BANA KICKS ASS
by jigga422
Feb 13th, 2004
04:49:12 AM
You know how it works, the same thing that's been done to death
by Captain Dobie
Feb 13th, 2004
04:54:15 AM
This PG-13 stuff will kill this movie...
by stackpointer
Feb 13th, 2004
05:05:32 AM
Brad Pitt is still a fag!
by mbaker
Feb 13th, 2004
05:10:49 AM
"Trial" of Paris
by Stumanji
Feb 13th, 2004
05:15:22 AM
Another Paris sex romp?
by Shad0wfax
Feb 13th, 2004
05:24:27 AM
WTF?? NO GAY ROBOTS??
by Darth Phallus
Feb 13th, 2004
05:39:45 AM
Brad Pitt is this generations Tom Cruise
by Bcphil
Feb 13th, 2004
06:25:51 AM
Yep,
by Conan_the_Humble
Feb 13th, 2004
06:46:15 AM
What about Sean Bean?
by DannyOcean01
Feb 13th, 2004
07:17:10 AM
You know all those plot devices you've seen a thousand times?
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
07:49:05 AM
PG-13
by Phimseto
Feb 13th, 2004
07:49:09 AM
for Stumanji: reason for the war on Troy
by no-no
Feb 13th, 2004
08:01:55 AM
PG-13 bullshit
by godoffireinhell
Feb 13th, 2004
08:08:54 AM
Troy trailer
by Northerner82
Feb 13th, 2004
08:33:30 AM
Hollywood's mythology
by CurryIce
Feb 13th, 2004
08:38:30 AM
This historical background is...
by MichaelSean
Feb 13th, 2004
08:50:39 AM
Patroclus
by Recognizer
Feb 13th, 2004
08:55:12 AM
mea culpa
by Recognizer
Feb 13th, 2004
08:57:32 AM
On the History of Troy
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
09:03:18 AM
facts v fiction
by Wyrdy the Gerbil
Feb 13th, 2004
09:07:23 AM
a few points:
by ElRoboticoDiablo
Feb 13th, 2004
09:14:30 AM
Darth_Phallus, myname is nobody, and anyone else still harping o
by raw_bean
Feb 13th, 2004
09:27:03 AM
For the record
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
09:38:12 AM
I loved my Greek Mythology class in college so I am geeked to se
by Lost Skeleton
Feb 13th, 2004
09:43:29 AM
Helen
by CuervoJones
Feb 13th, 2004
09:44:54 AM
This generations Tom Cruise?
by REDD
Feb 13th, 2004
09:45:51 AM
NEW RULE: PG-13 is a rating for pussies. Either go kid-friendly
by Bill Maher
Feb 13th, 2004
09:47:45 AM
I'm sorry but when it comes to serious ass kicking..
by JAGUART
Feb 13th, 2004
09:48:02 AM
A hard " R " Warners only want soft and fluffy!!!!
by 5secondfuse
Feb 13th, 2004
09:55:14 AM
Brian Cox with long hair...
by GreedoNeverShot
Feb 13th, 2004
10:00:17 AM
Sing, O Muse!
by Hud
Feb 13th, 2004
10:25:13 AM
this movie has some of the best casting I've seen in awhile.
by Bourne GreyElf
Feb 13th, 2004
10:29:22 AM
no-no: technically, Helen of Sparta
by Hud
Feb 13th, 2004
10:30:56 AM
agamemnon, achilles, paris, patroclus, et al
by capt jack aubrey
Feb 13th, 2004
10:31:40 AM

by ReDWasK
Feb 13th, 2004
11:00:56 AM
On the issue of homo war scenes with Pitt and Bana and, and gay
by Robofag
Feb 13th, 2004
11:08:09 AM
How about a spoiler warning next time, Redwask?
by Recognizer
Feb 13th, 2004
11:08:56 AM
Bwahahaha, take THAT stupid people who don't read the essential
by George Newman
Feb 13th, 2004
11:16:51 AM
The Scarecrow
by George Newman
Feb 13th, 2004
11:28:14 AM
Why Bother?
by Pandas-R-Us
Feb 13th, 2004
11:39:09 AM
Age of Bronze
by Antboy
Feb 13th, 2004
11:43:04 AM
LIAM NEESON IS RA'S AL GHUL!!!!!! PASS IT ON
by 007-11
Feb 13th, 2004
11:43:36 AM
I, too, prefer the Cox Lecter
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
11:46:15 AM
Only for Eric Bana...
by viola123
Feb 13th, 2004
11:54:41 AM
Is the Kraken in this flick or what?
by Nice Marmot
Feb 13th, 2004
11:56:19 AM
AntBoy:
by ElRoboticoDiablo
Feb 13th, 2004
11:56:36 AM
illium
by Antboy
Feb 13th, 2004
12:09:48 PM
hey bonehead
by hector
Feb 13th, 2004
12:21:49 PM
alright talkbackers, calling this a plant does not make you smar
by perryfarrell
Feb 13th, 2004
12:23:00 PM
hey hector
by perryfarrell
Feb 13th, 2004
12:24:57 PM
"here with a review of the first screened cut of TROY, the new W
by ScreamingPenis
Feb 13th, 2004
12:26:44 PM
Gates of Fire
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
12:31:59 PM
Cool Review but....
by warriorlittle
Feb 13th, 2004
12:38:52 PM
AntBoy and Frank:
by ElRoboticoDiablo
Feb 13th, 2004
12:43:45 PM
Yeah wtf? He didn't mention Sean Bean at all...
by Dragonfire
Feb 13th, 2004
12:49:39 PM
warriorlittle
by perryfarrell
Feb 13th, 2004
12:51:01 PM
Gay Sex in TROY?
by godoffireinhell
Feb 13th, 2004
01:01:22 PM
Sound like BS
by AlwaysThere
Feb 13th, 2004
01:04:03 PM
Troilus & Cressida
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
01:10:01 PM
mmmm.... historical gay sex.......
by perryfarrell
Feb 13th, 2004
01:14:09 PM
I also loved the way...
by Shad0wfax
Feb 13th, 2004
01:29:20 PM
[/sarcasm]
by perryfarrell
Feb 13th, 2004
01:32:34 PM
"The Road Warrior" and "Flesh+Blood"
by Some Dude
Feb 13th, 2004
01:38:32 PM
Ummm...Cassandra?
by Aeglos Istarion
Feb 13th, 2004
01:40:13 PM
History lesson...
by Hippo-Eki
Feb 13th, 2004
01:51:59 PM
still comparing every fight scene to Matrix Reloaded are we?
by Anomaly
Feb 13th, 2004
02:04:00 PM
Casting
by Creflo A. Dollar
Feb 13th, 2004
02:30:25 PM
i want to kill hulk hogan
by perryfarrell
Feb 13th, 2004
02:33:10 PM
PLANT!
by Phildogger
Feb 13th, 2004
02:55:04 PM
more spoilers
by Some Dude
Feb 13th, 2004
03:12:22 PM
They should have made "Trojan" instead...
by Some Dude
Feb 13th, 2004
03:13:21 PM
I hope that you guys complaining about giving away the ending of
by Blue_Demon
Feb 13th, 2004
04:13:11 PM
Achillis' "cousin"
by podunk411
Feb 13th, 2004
05:00:10 PM
PG-13
by darthboromir
Feb 13th, 2004
05:01:10 PM
Hats off to Orlando Bloom
by FrankCobretti
Feb 13th, 2004
05:02:19 PM
Schliemann and Agamemnon
by Penthesilea
Feb 13th, 2004
05:09:09 PM
(singing:) Neverending story... woo-oo-oo-, woo-oo-oo, woo-oo-oo
by Thing-Fish
Feb 13th, 2004
05:37:41 PM
I just want to thank all the talk-backers - honestly!
by Swithin
Feb 13th, 2004
06:12:31 PM
Do Paris and Helen get away?
by fabjax
Feb 13th, 2004
06:26:48 PM
cousin my ass...
by Bunger
Feb 13th, 2004
07:15:12 PM
Woohoo!!
by gil-galad12
Feb 13th, 2004
07:17:15 PM
Good point Swithin
by Thing-Fish
Feb 13th, 2004
07:20:59 PM
"the performance of the horse is too wooden"
by Thing-Fish
Feb 13th, 2004
07:22:36 PM
Rerelease for Oscar Season 2005 Poster Blurb: "Helen of Troy Tit
by Trav McGee
Feb 13th, 2004
07:52:27 PM
Dummy, it's the "GREEK ARMY" not the "SPARTAN ARMY". Sparta was
by jackburton2003
Feb 13th, 2004
08:08:44 PM
Well, it's been over ten years since I read it
by Trav McGee
Feb 13th, 2004
08:11:15 PM
Fuck PG-13
by Smurfette
Feb 13th, 2004
09:52:27 PM
Trav
by FluffyUnbound
Feb 13th, 2004
10:17:35 PM
ANGEL HAS BEEN CANCELLED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by mpfanatic
Feb 14th, 2004
12:44:47 AM
Re: Evenly spaced ships and PG-13/R rating
by Lord_Soth
Feb 14th, 2004
03:48:16 AM
Cant wait for Piece of sh&t Hollywood to ruin other classics
by Bong
Feb 14th, 2004
05:04:34 AM
On ratings...
by Swithin
Feb 14th, 2004
05:58:58 AM
On ratings (again - stupid enter key)
by Swithin
Feb 14th, 2004
06:06:32 AM
Heh... correcting myself.
by Swithin
Feb 14th, 2004
06:12:01 AM
Movie of 2004?
by beano
Feb 14th, 2004
06:37:45 AM
mynameisnobody and clashing armies
by Foozwack
Feb 14th, 2004
06:38:39 AM
Yes, the ratings system MUST GO.
by FluffyUnbound
Feb 14th, 2004
08:33:26 AM
Gotcha Fluffy
by Trav McGee
Feb 14th, 2004
09:26:23 AM
just to set the record straight
by the geat
Feb 14th, 2004
10:08:44 AM
oh never mind
by the geat
Feb 14th, 2004
10:13:32 AM
Ye Gods
by John Nefastis
Feb 14th, 2004
10:16:42 AM
Um, PG-13 GLadiator?
by DukeDeMondo
Feb 14th, 2004
10:17:49 AM
bonk of 37
by fbsthreads
Feb 14th, 2004
11:38:19 AM
R rating
by teen15wonder
Feb 14th, 2004
12:13:50 PM
Yeah, but is there a Trojan horse in it???
by Joe Cool #2
Feb 14th, 2004
01:11:17 PM
Holy shit...
by JoJoBea
Feb 14th, 2004
06:32:04 PM
The True Paris
by legolaslover2003
Feb 14th, 2004
06:57:59 PM
Maybe Paris will go AWOL from the Trojan National Guard and lie
by Bill Maher
Feb 14th, 2004
08:22:58 PM
legolaslover2003
by JoJoBea
Feb 14th, 2004
08:27:28 PM
Now that, Dick Hertz was fucking hilarious
by MyGlockYourMouth
Feb 14th, 2004
08:30:39 PM
The Ship Scene Is Probably Pretty Accurate
by Farging Bastige
Feb 14th, 2004
10:26:38 PM
BladeRunnerUnit
by MisterBlonde
Feb 14th, 2004
11:37:51 PM
Legolaslover2003, great post!
by Swithin
Feb 14th, 2004
11:38:59 PM
Sounds great just so long as they don't mess it up by trying to
by Gere's AssGerbil
Feb 15th, 2004
02:13:16 AM
I also saw Troy this past Thursday night
by iluvmovies
Feb 15th, 2004
03:24:30 AM
Re: CGI soldiers
by Lord_Soth
Feb 15th, 2004
03:54:05 AM
EVERYTHING sounds "utterly fantastic" to industry cocksucker Har
by Jerkwald Loser
Feb 15th, 2004
05:27:19 AM
EdWood
by DocPazuzu
Feb 15th, 2004
09:44:15 AM
I won't disagree, MyNameIsNobody
by Farging Bastige
Feb 15th, 2004
09:51:16 AM
Sean Bean
by Danger Mouse
Feb 15th, 2004
06:04:37 PM
KICK ASS MOVIE WITH TITS & ASS!
by el zar
Feb 15th, 2004
09:02:50 PM
ratings, sean bean and the main characters
by steffie8890
Feb 15th, 2004
09:44:05 PM
Musa
by BillEmic
Feb 15th, 2004
09:56:13 PM
Achiles
by Moregan
Feb 15th, 2004
11:05:39 PM
So, uh...what do you mean by 'public revelations?'
by dillene
Feb 15th, 2004
11:31:34 PM
"the next sexy tomboy beanpole"..looks like some "original" mark
by Bong
Feb 16th, 2004
02:16:21 AM
Scarily enough, the reviewer didn't say 'public revelations', bu
by raw_bean
Feb 17th, 2004
06:05:17 AM
tedious battle sequences
by neardark
Feb 17th, 2004
06:16:01 AM
MYNAMEISNOBODY, (IF YOU CAN FIND THIS THEN EITHER THE HOSINGS FI
by raw_bean
Feb 17th, 2004
06:24:28 AM
AAARRGGGHHHHH! Garbled nonsense, sorry. I'll repeat the post her
by raw_bean
Feb 17th, 2004
06:29:30 AM
Neardark, Sean Bean as Faramir as well as Boromir? Yeesh, God no
by raw_bean
Feb 17th, 2004
06:41:30 AM
T"hey look pretty bad...just like the ones within LOTR. MASSIVE
by minderbinder
Feb 17th, 2004
09:30:25 AM
T"hey look pretty bad...just like the ones within LOTR. MASSIVE
by minderbinder
Feb 17th, 2004
09:58:47 AM
T"hey look pretty bad...just like the ones within LOTR. MASSIVE
by minderbinder
Feb 17th, 2004
10:19:29 AM
legolaslover2003
by under_five_feet
Feb 20th, 2004
08:52:08 PM
Cassandra
by BlueStarlight
Apr 2nd, 2004
06:54:21 PM
ORLANDO BLOOM!!!
by koolgirl08
Apr 20th, 2004
06:22:46 PM
non-cgi armies
by Ostrogoth
May 3rd, 2004
02:35:43 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.