Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Do The Critics Have A Bad Feeling About The Cartoon Network’s Tartakovsky-Free STAR WARS: THE CLONE WARS?

I am – Hercules!!



I’ve got a bad feeling about “Star Wars: The Clone Wars,” the new TV series premiering tonight on The Cartoon Network. It’s from the same creative team that brought us August’s “Clone Wars” movie, which garnered 96% negative reviews among “top critics” surveyed by Rotten Tomatoes – and 100% negative reviews from everybody I’ve talked to about it. (The Tomatoes survey would have been 100% negative if not for the notice authored by the Arizona Republic’s Kerry Lengel, who appraised the movie as “surprisingly unterrible.”)

The screeners for the series seem to have gone out to far fewer media outlets than did screening passes for the movie, and the few critics who have seen the TV version of “Clone Wars” seem to be kinder to the two episodes airing tonight. Did LucasFilm really choose inferior episodes for the movie – which people had to drive down to a cinema to pay for – or are TV critics just far, far less discriminating than their movie counterparts?

Entertainment Weekly says:

Older Star Wars fans loathed The Clone Wars, George Lucas' movie 'toon about prequel-era Obi-Wan and Anakin. At least the TV spin-off is decent — definitely more suspenseful and character-centric than the bombastic pilot flick. Its target audience — kids — will dig it. And middle-aged haters will hate it a little less. …

The Los Angeles Times says:

I'm one of those who thinks that with regards to the "Star Wars" saga, it's all been mostly downhill since "The Empire Strikes Back," except, of course, Carrie Fisher in slave gear for "Return of the Jedi." … There may come a day when reality is perfectly counterfeited by computers, but here in the early 21st century, animators have yet to conquer the human problem: digitally rendered people look creepy. …

The Chicago Tribune says:

… little about "Clone Wars" is involving. … Complexity is fine, but when the plot is Byzantine and the characters lack all depth, the result is either irritation or boredom. The overall blandness means it's hard to care for whomever is blowing stuff up on the screen. The clone armies are led by Jedi such as Anakin Skywalker, who's a bit of a pill and who, as anyone who's seen the "Star Wars" films knows, later turns into Darth Vader. The Jedi themselves are working for Chancellor Palpatine, who is nobody's idea of an enlightened leader. So, it's a robot army versus clones working for a creepy despot. Go, um, team?

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette says:

The computer-animated movie "Star Wars: The Clone Wars" was a dud at the box office (less than $40 million in domestic gross) and was lambasted by critics, but the Cartoon Network series of the same name may fare better. The first two half-hour episodes are less raucous and seemingly more adult than the film. There's more attention to character development; Jabba the Hutt's flamboyant uncle isn't anywhere to be found. …

The Boston Herald says:

… The wise-cracking battle ’droids - the intergalactic Larry, Moe and Curley - are in abundance but appear even more useless and less amusing than in the films. … The stylized animation ranges from impressive in the case of anything mechanical to waxy and lifeless in the case of anything human. Faces appear stiff and expressionless, which might make Hayden Christensen fans feel at home with yet another wooden Anakin. … still doesn’t redeem Lucas’ attempted do-over and the Greedo-shoots-first syndrome, but it’s certainly no “Star Wars Holiday Special.”

The Hollywood Reporter says:

… Chances are if you liked "Star Wars," you'll enjoy the TV series. When it comes to extending the franchise and attracting a new generation of "Star Wars" fans, the force is definitely with George Lucas. …

Variety says:

… the half-hour episodes are so jam-packed with action the clunky dialogue flies by less obtrusively, and the irritating characters have less time to annoy. … Of course, technical wizardry has never been a problem for series steward George Lucas. His shortcomings rather have to do with a too-casual acquaintance with the written word, and a penchant for wince-inducing comedy aimed at kids. Those drawbacks persist …

9 p.m. Friday. The Cartoon Network.



From The Guy Who Wrote

The Making of Star Wars

And The Guy Who Wrote

Star Wars: The Annotated Screenplays!!


$13.49 Dawn of the Dead!!
$13.95 Road Warrior!!
$13.95 A Clockwork Orange!
$13.95 The Fugitive!
$14.95 The Shining!!
SuperCheap Blu-Ray!!


AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login


Reader Talkback


by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:17:30 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:18:27 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:20:26 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:21:06 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:22:06 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:22:51 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:24:14 AM
It's 5 am, you douche.
by Strabo
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:24:30 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:24:38 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:25:08 AM
It is on the east coast.
by Strabo
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:26:13 AM
5:28 here
by GavinVanDraven
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:27:09 AM
illiterate wanderer
by FrodoFraggins
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:28:05 AM
I'll guess bored.
by Strabo
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:28:19 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:31:11 AM

by Literarywanderer
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:33:17 AM
The damage has been done
by tomdolan04
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:40:15 AM
the movie was incredible
by Obscura
Oct 3rd, 2008
04:41:10 AM
I'll watch this...
by Bob Loblaw Law Blog
Oct 3rd, 2008
05:02:21 AM

by Six Demon Bag
Oct 3rd, 2008
05:16:19 AM
"Insert Witty Title Here"
by deanbarry
Oct 3rd, 2008
06:39:02 AM
It's for KIDS, motherfuckers...
by Banzai Rootskibango
Oct 3rd, 2008
06:41:13 AM
so, if it's for kids...
by only1
Oct 3rd, 2008
06:50:37 AM
What no DVR?
by Dazzler69
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:18:23 AM
"The Force Is Definitely With George Lucas"
by Darth Busey
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:27:55 AM
Spellbindingly Awful
by A G
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:47:07 AM
In HD?
by Abin Sur
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:51:55 AM
When does the movie come out on DVD?
by rev_skarekroe
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:04:29 AM
Drop the "it's for kids shit" already
by aboriginal
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:14:39 AM
Goddammit.
by Smashing
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:17:05 AM
Much better!
by Emixxary
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:47:55 AM
Since when does popular opinion or critics matter?
by Redfive!
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:54:12 AM
If Harry wrote a positive review...
by palpeedude
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:01:19 AM
Shiny turds are still turds
by Kentucky Colonel
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:15:00 AM
For a franchise that ended in 1980...
by performingmonkey
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:29:52 AM
aboriginal, I hear you but I resent your "expendable capitol"
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:32:09 AM
You say there's spaceships and lasers?
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:34:20 AM
Then move on.
by TheLastCleric
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:49:56 AM
Y'know I know someone's gonna hate me for saying this...
by superhero
Oct 3rd, 2008
10:45:05 AM
yep, its for kids and morons
by ls420
Oct 3rd, 2008
11:11:31 AM
re: The Clone Wars "film"
by hobsnobber
Oct 3rd, 2008
11:27:54 AM
Spellbindingly Awesome at BEING AWFUL
by A G
Oct 3rd, 2008
12:23:37 PM
I see the Lucas double standard is still in effect
by Liberty Valance
Oct 3rd, 2008
12:28:59 PM
The CW film was just as good as the live action films
by Sith Witch
Oct 3rd, 2008
12:33:39 PM
Wow, such feelings...
by herr_howard
Oct 3rd, 2008
12:51:58 PM
The Star Wars Universe has soured so much
by TroutMaskReplicant
Oct 3rd, 2008
01:09:56 PM
Oh, yeah, and then there are THESE reviews, too
by Termigoonie
Oct 3rd, 2008
01:15:18 PM
Time to
by Melvin_Pelvis
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:01:08 PM
Correction, Melvin
by Termigoonie
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:09:43 PM
All These Haters Are
by DRACULA_WANTS_THE_AMULET
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:19:18 PM
Re: Liberty Valence
by Cobbio
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:30:02 PM
Am I the only one
by shran
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:36:20 PM
Termigoonie
by Melvin_Pelvis
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:39:55 PM
i care so little i lost interest in reading the reviews.
by alice 13
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:43:30 PM
shran
by Melvin_Pelvis
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:44:09 PM
Forward
by Cobbio
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:47:03 PM
Star Wars?...
by Kid Z
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:55:32 PM
How about
by shran
Oct 3rd, 2008
02:57:20 PM
What's with all the hate for this?
by codymr
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:11:19 PM
Cobbio:
by Sith Witch
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:12:11 PM
Only 1...
by Banzai Rootskibango
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:13:31 PM
CLONE WARS IS FUN!
by Earthquake WestCoast
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:26:10 PM
Director speaks
by plocock
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:28:33 PM
Plocock:
by Sith Witch
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:47:31 PM
Earthquake Westcoast...
by Banzai Rootskibango
Oct 3rd, 2008
03:49:35 PM
If this show was really for kids...
by Greenleaf1
Oct 3rd, 2008
05:12:16 PM
Yeah, but you liked Wondefalls, Herc.
by 18to88
Oct 3rd, 2008
05:12:39 PM
Eh, Jedi use lightsabers and shit blows up in Star Wars universe
by TallBoy66
Oct 3rd, 2008
05:17:13 PM
Original Clone Wars series was still better
by TallBoy66
Oct 3rd, 2008
05:19:42 PM
"middle-aged haters will hate it a little less..."
by Napoleon Park
Oct 3rd, 2008
06:09:25 PM
Isn't everyone tired of Star Wars
by Phategod2
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:06:04 PM
Not the Cool Thing
by Phategod2
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:13:17 PM
You know what I hate?
by Harold-Sherbort
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:22:22 PM
I hate to break this to you, Phategod2
by I Dunno
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:32:04 PM
lets all bitch
by anakinsoyo
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:39:17 PM
I know
by Phategod2
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:40:59 PM
why are people talking about star trek
by anakinsoyo
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:47:32 PM
I didn't like Wonderfalls.
by Hercules
Oct 3rd, 2008
07:53:09 PM
The First Episode was Great- Fuck the Haters!
by DRACULA_WANTS_THE_AMULET
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:31:30 PM
the problem with the ulti-whiners is...
by crankyoldguy
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:41:48 PM
And when will Herc have a blogspot w/ pals...
by crankyoldguy
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:42:53 PM
this series IS worth watching......
by j2talk
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:44:33 PM
Death and Violence
by DRACULA_WANTS_THE_AMULET
Oct 3rd, 2008
08:53:33 PM
Pretty Damn Good
by galoot
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:05:00 PM
Yoda was the shit, good to see him being mischievous again.
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:09:37 PM
2nd show was OK, I expected more submarine homage.
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:11:16 PM
Submarines
by galoot
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:12:20 PM
The character animation is lacking; Force Unleashed was a better
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:13:52 PM
con't... design.
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:15:36 PM
More hunter-killer sub action would've been sweet.
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:17:07 PM
Genndy's brilliant storytelling
by Mose Schrute
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:20:09 PM
Wait till Episode 3...
by TMW
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:30:16 PM
Not too bad.
by Rando Calrisian
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:42:00 PM
Best part of tonight was.....
by Robnhud
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:43:13 PM
Mose Schrute, get back to beat harvest.
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 3rd, 2008
09:53:23 PM
Only Two Good Star Wars Films Have Ever Been Produced!!!
by Media Messiah
Oct 3rd, 2008
10:35:29 PM
Somebody please just put out Droids on DVD...
by tangcameo
Oct 3rd, 2008
10:38:26 PM
Add to friends...
by jsm1978
Oct 3rd, 2008
10:49:37 PM
My thoughts....
by Thrillho77
Oct 3rd, 2008
10:49:44 PM
Wasnt expecting it
by studioki
Oct 4th, 2008
12:10:30 AM
hmmm
by slkboxrman
Oct 4th, 2008
12:54:31 AM
MEH
by wackybantha
Oct 4th, 2008
12:55:05 AM
No one should really care.
by kirttrik
Oct 4th, 2008
02:41:10 AM
A New Hope was for kids, EmpireSB was for kids
by Reelheed
Oct 4th, 2008
03:29:52 AM
You know, for kids....
by theycallmemrglass
Oct 4th, 2008
04:18:03 AM
It's for KIDS and KIDS ONLY WATCH COMPLETE SHIT
by A G
Oct 4th, 2008
05:24:35 AM
I've seen worse
by Whitemouse
Oct 4th, 2008
08:14:55 AM
A few questions:
by catlettuce4
Oct 4th, 2008
08:33:47 AM
THE TARGET AUDIENCE IS CHILDREN!
by fedrich519
Oct 4th, 2008
08:36:18 AM
My 3 month year old loved the Clone Wars...
by Leafar the Lost
Oct 4th, 2008
08:59:10 AM
Very good.....
by j2talk
Oct 4th, 2008
09:11:23 AM
SLKBOXRMAN:
by Sith Witch
Oct 4th, 2008
09:41:49 AM
Did any of you even watch it?
by Vonfolger
Oct 4th, 2008
10:08:44 AM
Stupid, Stupid HYPED ANNOUNCER RUINS START OF SHOW!
by MrStinger
Oct 4th, 2008
10:31:12 AM
I wonder how it would have went down in the 80s
by Arteska
Oct 4th, 2008
10:42:59 AM
i prefer the annoucer over the crawl
by j2talk
Oct 4th, 2008
12:28:29 PM
My Name's JediBobster, and I'm a Star Wars fan.
by Jedibobster
Oct 4th, 2008
12:32:42 PM
Pretty good start - Has potential
by 18to88
Oct 4th, 2008
12:43:33 PM
Jedibobster
by Arteska
Oct 4th, 2008
12:55:05 PM
I don't give a sith ..!
by Stalkeye
Oct 4th, 2008
01:14:24 PM
umm i don't get it
by olson71
Oct 4th, 2008
01:48:56 PM
Oh yeah, the announcer
by Thrillho77
Oct 4th, 2008
01:52:39 PM
olson71:
by Sith Witch
Oct 4th, 2008
02:18:48 PM
I liked it
by LarryTate
Oct 4th, 2008
03:49:29 PM
Can I get more commercials with my clone wars?
by alienindisguise
Oct 4th, 2008
03:55:44 PM
sith witch
by slkboxrman
Oct 4th, 2008
06:26:31 PM
Guess what the clone wars aren't that interesting.
by Orionsangels
Oct 4th, 2008
07:42:20 PM
Quite honestly
by Orionsangels
Oct 4th, 2008
07:42:55 PM
why no Vader?? Because
by j2talk
Oct 4th, 2008
08:06:33 PM
clone wars aren't that interesting;BULL
by j2talk
Oct 4th, 2008
08:15:23 PM
THE DROIDS ARE EVIL SICK!
by Earthquake WestCoast
Oct 4th, 2008
09:17:53 PM
THE CLONE WARS WERE AWESOME!
by Earthquake WestCoast
Oct 4th, 2008
09:22:21 PM
END THE SERIES WITH A REMAKE OF "REVENGE OF THE SITH"
by Earthquake WestCoast
Oct 4th, 2008
09:28:58 PM
What happened to the other clone wars animted series?
by happybunni
Oct 4th, 2008
09:43:51 PM
If you like Star Wars
by Arteska
Oct 4th, 2008
10:29:15 PM
Good start so far
by MrD
Oct 4th, 2008
10:42:21 PM
Fuck you, Lucas.
by SlickyVonBoner
Oct 4th, 2008
11:17:48 PM
I love these talkbacks...
by BizarroJerry
Oct 5th, 2008
12:27:19 AM
There was that preview of a JAR JAR episode...
by Stereotypical Evil Archer
Oct 5th, 2008
01:38:03 AM
Be a citizen!
by Blackguard
Oct 5th, 2008
01:41:16 AM
It was GOOD!
by Banzai Rootskibango
Oct 5th, 2008
02:42:29 AM
There is talk about a Force Unleashed Movie..
by Stalkeye
Oct 5th, 2008
07:24:57 AM
Why watch Clone Wars when there's..
by Stalkeye
Oct 5th, 2008
07:30:09 AM
Re: The Force Unleashed
by j2talk
Oct 5th, 2008
09:19:34 AM
Yes, I can't wait for the live action series...
by Leafar the Lost
Oct 5th, 2008
09:27:40 AM
Lucas Should keep turning out new StarWars FOREVER
by j2talk
Oct 5th, 2008
09:33:40 AM
150% better than the theatrical version
by JabbaPapa
Oct 5th, 2008
10:34:09 AM
SLKBOXRMAN:
by Sith Witch
Oct 5th, 2008
11:34:45 AM
Arteska: "If you like Star Wars..."
by codymr
Oct 5th, 2008
12:55:38 PM
Any non-plants see this?
by Chief Joseph
Oct 5th, 2008
03:51:21 PM
It's funny. We all thought Ewoks were as bad as it could get.
by alienindisguise
Oct 5th, 2008
04:14:44 PM
Chief Joseph:
by Sith Witch
Oct 5th, 2008
04:48:27 PM
To clarify,
by Sith Witch
Oct 5th, 2008
05:03:13 PM
Hated the movie, really enjoyed the series premier
by JackSack
Oct 5th, 2008
07:07:15 PM
Yoda rules
by Supermans
Oct 5th, 2008
07:20:47 PM
I don't like the way Yoda talks anymore.
by Mockingbuddha
Oct 5th, 2008
11:04:00 PM
Well, critics said it didn't feel like a MOVIE, right?
by Drath
Oct 6th, 2008
09:32:30 AM
I dug the Clone Wars movie.
by pap
Oct 6th, 2008
04:36:37 PM
And btw, Anakin...
by pap
Oct 6th, 2008
04:38:52 PM
And btw, btw...
by pap
Oct 6th, 2008
04:43:50 PM
BTW BTW BTW
by Orcus
Oct 8th, 2008
08:13:50 AM
Lucas is an experimental filmmaker...
by JabbaPapa
Oct 8th, 2008
03:29:03 PM
Holy shit, I LIKED it!!!
by Drath
Oct 9th, 2008
09:14:25 PM
Now Orcus has to d/l the damn thing
by Orcus
Oct 13th, 2008
09:49:19 AM
Known Talkbacker here.
by ZeroCorpse
Oct 18th, 2008
06:38:09 PM
Who ho! Looks like Orcus is not the only oldie here
by Orcus
Oct 18th, 2008
07:53:40 PM
Since Herc isn't doing ANY Clone Wars TBs...
by ZeroCorpse
Oct 18th, 2008
08:56:46 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.